Video Reports

This is the place to post your comments/reports on the videos watched in class or watched on your own from the World of Music videos. (We have watched video 4 "Transmission" , video 7 "Timbre", video 8 "Texture" and video 11 "Composers and Improvisers" from this series.You can also watch video 6 "Melody" and video 9 "Harmony" and write about them if you so choose.)

On October 4, we watched "The Gateway to Rhythm" with John McLaughlin and S. Ganesh Vinayakram.. If you missed it, or if you wish to review it, you can look on you tube for John McLaughlin and Konokol, and there are something like 11 hits.

October 18, we watched "Bringing the music of Bali to BYU".

30 comments:

Scott said...

The in class movie
Scott Christian

Well I think that every way to learn is a little different but that doesn’t say that it is wrong. I personally am very very dyslexic and so how I learn is very different than how a normal person will learn. Every way that was shown in the movie is very helpful in its own way and form. I don’t think there is a wrong way to learn to say but different methods. There are so many methods even within the western way of teaching music. Each tutor will require a different book to start with to say in the violin there is the Suzuki method and many others. Then there is how much time you are actually with your tutor in practice.
Personally I feel that the way the Japanese were teaching would work best for me. I feel this way because if I watch some one do something then I can do it but just from reading it off of sheet music to say I have a harder time finding the melody and the rithum of the song or the peace that I am working with. I also thing that the way the way they teach in India to be very interesting and that it could work very well if the person learning already knows how to play. The instructor is only helping and teaching the student new forms and ways to play widening his ability to be more versatile. The way the religious singers learned to sing the sung I found to be true to me also. If I can hear someone else singing with me I can match them and then in that I can see what is my mistakes and learn and grow by listening to others that are better then me.
So we see that there are many way to learn music and grow. I feel they all have a time and a place to help us (being those who play music) to become better. At first we all need a one on one teach to teach how to hold our instrument correctly and then with time we may just need a few pointers from someone that knows more than us to help us along the path.

Anneli & Jordan said...

Transmission Learning Music Video
Anneli Fielding

Transmission is the learning and teaching of music. Music can be learned or taught by family, teachers or recordings. Music is like learning a language. It must be heard and imitated. The learner must have a good model and good ears. They must perceive slight details. I feel that while a person is still learning music, they should do everything they can to imitate professionals. Listening is so important because as Keith Richardson said, “Everything you’ve ever listened to comes out when you play.”
The video showed a gospel choir that would learn their music and parts by ear in order to make the music a part of each performer. When a person has their music memorized, it is so much easier to perform with great emotion. I think that learning the music by ear might help the performance even more because the performer never relied on the music so they were not afraid of forgetting something.
Transmission through notation is when a composer writes down their music and the learner learns from written music. This is essentially how the composer communicates to the performer. In the past, composers wrote little details either because it was obvious or they didn’t care how a certain element was performed. Now music has a lot more details such as which instruments, style, tempo, and dynamics.
Different cultures have different learning and teaching styles. In Japan the teacher is always playing along with the student. In India, the student lives with the master and does chores in order to receive lessons. The lessons can be very impromtu so the student has to be ready to learn at all times.
I like that the video said that we can learn from anyone. Part of our soul is transmitted when we teach, learn, or perform. One of my favorite quotes is “For heights and depths no words can reach, music is the soul’s own speech.” This is why people enjoy listening and playing music.

Scott said...

In-class movie # 2

I found it to be very interesting that the sound that on instruments makes would be distinguished by these under lying sounds. But taking to time to actually think about it it dose make sense. I know that in the violin it isn’t jus the strings that make the sound. It has to do with the bridge on the violin and the quality of this bridge can determine a lot in its quality of sound. On the inside of a violin there is a wooden dowel that touches the top and the bottom faces of the violin this to plays a part in its quality of sound. So where this dowel and the quality of the bridge would be like what the man was saying about the flute he was playing. It isn’t large changes but tiny one like the size of the finger hole or the thickness of the flutes walls.

In this it also make me think of what we were told on the music tour to BYU about the lute. She told us that the best lute are made out of more kinds of wood, and that is what will give it a good quality of sound. There really are many different factors that play into the creation of the sound that one instrument plays. It can also be in the quality of stings on a sting instrument or if they are metal or nylon on a guitar, each makes a very distinct sound but yet out of the same instrument.

I found it to be very interesting the vegetable orchestra. With each vegetable they were able to make a distinct sound but yet each one was familiar to an instrument. Personally I wouldn’t have been about to tell you that they were play on vegetables if I was just lessening to them. I would have thought that they were drums, flute, recorders and other and other to say little kid instruments. The really have found a great way to relocate sound in a way that is very unique and artistic.

There are many other way to remake sounds and I think that with time we will find more bands like this one and ones like “Stomp” that make music out of thinks that we would never have thought of. they will turn noise witch is un organized sound into something organized and with structure making it to be music.

Anneli & Jordan said...

Anneli Fielding
Timbre: The Color of Music

Timbre or tone color is what makes the violin sound different from a flute. If you played the same note on lots of different instruments, they would all sound different even though the fundamental pitch is the same. This difference is due to the mix of the overtones along with the fundamental note. When a note is played or sung, there is a series of overtones that are being played simultaneous. In the video, a synthesizer changed the overtone structure and showed a graph of the sound waves.
Different timbres are classified into groups: membranophones, aerophones, idiophones, chordophones, and electrophones. Membranophones are defined as a stretched skin that is struck and vibrates. Aerophones have a vibrating column of air flowing through it. Idiophones, like bells, the actual body of the instrument vibrates. Chordophones sound from vibrating strings. Electrophones are a relatively new category that uses a wire to make an analogous waveform.
Materials and construction are vital to determine the timbre. But it is the instrumentalist makes the music come to life. Lots of instruments can play contrasting styles. Essentially, the timbre can change just by the way it is played.
The human voice is the most flexible in different timbres. It was really interesting to hear so many types of voices sing. Each individual’s voice has a different timbre. Different cultures have different ways of singing, which creates a different timbre.
The use of timbre was different in renaissance time than it is today. Early artists played lots more instruments because the timbres are more limited than instruments today. They would play different instruments throughout their performance in order produce a variety of tone colors.

Myrna said...

Kristy has written a report on video #2, Timbre, which she handed in to me.

Aileen Keliiliki said...

“The Gateway to Rhythm” starring John McLaughlin and Selva Ganesh Linayakram:
When the movie first began, John McLaughlin gave us an introduction to the method of counting and improvising rhythm in India, called Konokol, or Konnakol. I have to admit that at first I was pretty skeptical, wondering how replacing Indian words such as Ta or Da for One, and Taka instead of saying One-And, and so on, would make sense to western music. John promised us that we could use this method of counting rhythm with any style of music, western, eastern, asian, etc. So, I watched, and expected to be impressed. I was.
After the first example given by Selva, a professional musician in India, I was hooked; mouth dropping open and everything. It all made sense! The Indian words didn’t match up to every single note value as western music does, but matched up to groupings of notes instead. A group of three notes was always said as Takita, and a group of four notes were always said as Takadimi or TakaJuno depending on if you wanted an accent on the third note or not. No matter if the groupings were in sixteenth notes or quarter notes, they were all said the same.
The movie went on to more complex rhythms, with more complex note groupings, including dotted notes and rests. If a rest fell during a word, like say for example, a group of four eighth notes with an eighth rest at the beginning, would be said like this in western music: _and-two-and. The word being Takadimi, “Ta” would just be eliminated, like this: _kadimi.
What amazed me the most, was how fast Selva could speak the Konokol groupings, and how easy it was for him to improvise. Because he already knew what each group was called, it’s easy for him to read rhythm quickly, and to improvise on-the-spot.
During the bonus features, we were able to watch a boy’s music school in India, perform a piece using Konokol written specifically for the advertisement. The boys were so cute, and to watch them get into the rhythm with their heads, hands, and body inspired me that kids can read rhythm well as much as we can!

Unknown said...

Video #7 report
I found this video on timbre and tone quality fascinating. One part of this video particularly got me thinking as to why I love the piano so much. In the video, an instrument maker explains that timbre is commanded by the musician themselves, the way the instrument is played affects the timbre, and if the instrumentalist doesn’t feel it, the audience won’t either. Later in the video, saxophonist explains that it is important for an instrumentalist to have some kind of connection with their instrument. He fawns over the versatility of tone qualities that a saxophone can produce. A saxophone can produce a soothing sound to produce a calm mood, but it can also sound very loud and commanding. Both these parts really got me thinking exactly what I love about the piano. I too think the piano is very versatile just as the saxophonist feels about his instrument. My belief is there is no type of mood in existence that you cannot express with the piano. You can strike the keys abruptly for an urgent feeling, or softly, gently for a more calming feeling. You can delight audiences, or even frighten audiences with just one single instrument. You can paint a picture in the listeners mind with music played on the piano. The amount of techniques on the piano are very extensive, you can make it sound like almost anything. Sounds in nature, household sounds, and every day sounds are no exception. The tone colors on the piano are endless, and the amount of sound that can be made on the piano is also enjoyable. A pianist doesn’t really need any other instruments to help it tell a story or create a certain mood (though piano concertos can be very beautiful.) I love the harmony that can be made on the piano, sometimes you can make it sound like a chorus of voices, or a symphony or orchestra; you can make it sound like other instruments, if certain technique is used, but it takes a little imagination on the listeners part to hear it.

Rachael said...

Rachael Purser
World Music
Reflection on Video
The Gateway to Rhythm

This video was very informational and entertaining. It went over how Indians learn rhythm. They use a method that simply uses their words for 1, 2, 3, and 4, for the most part. The words they start out with is Da, or one to us, Taka, two to us, Takita, three for us, and Taka Dimi, or four for us. This system of learning, with da, taka, takita, and taka dimi, is known as Konokol. Konokol is described in the video as being a system of mastering rhythm. While watching the video I found it interesting that each of their words has the same corresponding number of syllables in the word as the number it is representing.
Students soon master the basics and learn how to improv in any time signature. In the video Selva would teach us different parts of Konokol and then he would do an improv at the end of each chapter. If you paid attention you could have noticed that as he went on in different time signatures he would favor a certain word but could change it to be slower or faster as he desired. As the video went on he also started introducing different terms that they could interchange with the original terms. For example he would sometimes change Taka Dimi for Taka Juno. When he would change these two he would change the rhythm with a focus on Ta and Ju. He would hold these to sounds out a little longer to make the rhythm and the whole sound different. This method also helps to teach the different stylizations of songs.
This method of teaching rhythm I thought was very well thought out. It would provide the student with the knowledge necessary to be able to sight read any musical composition. It also puts them farther ahead then all the other students that learn rhythm as they go. This method of teaching I think would be helpful for all teachers to adapt with their students.

jchoffman said...

Video Report:
An Offering to Please God

This video was presented by some BYU music students about the music from Bali. The music is usually played at gatherings and social events. The musicians play from their heart and rarely for money. I think that is a very special attribute for people to do that, especially in the world now that is money driven, and greed is rampant. The Balinese music is based on their religion, and their religion is what keeps them alive. Gamelan can be very complicated, much like Western symphony. The instruments consist of gongs, drums, flutes, cymbals, bronze kettles, and bronze metalophones. A Gamelan set usually takes about six months to complete the construction there of. The wooden bases are carved, very meticulously I might add, out of a type of fruit wood. The carvings on the outside of the instruments tell stories, and are usually some type of nature scene. The scene design is created to ward off evil spirits. Once the wood bases are made, the bronze keys are shaped by the tuners. Similar instruments are purposely tuned at slightly different tones to give the effect, when played, of a shimery sound. I still haven't quite found an appreciation for the sound of Gamelan music yet. The girl in the video said it best, "It kind of sounds like someone banging on pots and pans in the kitchen". I think it still has to grow on me a little more. The Gamelan set is uniquely tuned to stay as a set. So, replacing an instrument in one set with an instrument from another set, simply is not possible. In the video, the music was compared to a type of irrigation used for growing rice. In order for all the crops to succeed, precise timing of irrigation is needed. Everything has to happen at the right time. Playing the music is just like that, timing has to be just right for the music to sound right. The BYU students who played in the video were very good. Even though the sound was kind of chaotic at times, it looked very difficult to play certain instruments. Hitting the bar with the mallet in one hand while deadening the sound with the other, looked very difficult to me. I thought it was a very interesting video.

Aileen Keliiliki said...

Bringing Bali to BYU- During this documentary on Gamelon music and bringing the instruments to BYU, I was amazed at the difficulty of forging the instruments, and the joyful spirits of the people of Indonesia.
Some instruments take from several to up to 6 months to create, and part of it is the incredible carvings in the instruments. I was in awe at how intricate and beautiful the designs were. The people in Bali say that they have to cover the instruments with lots of designs, leaving no space for the demon/ devil to inhabit the instrument.
I liked how the designs would often depict myths, or Indonesian stories that incorporate symbolism and teaching morals. This provides not only artistic views of Bali, but also gives the players, Indonesian or not, a sense of being involved with the Indonesian culture spiritually as well as musically.
I was also impressed with how easily and willing they were, in letting the gamelon set that was being made for BYU, include the LDS sunstone design. Knowing that the people in Bali are very spiritual and religious, I thought that the host of the film would say how difficult it was to get the design carved into BYU’s gamelon instruments. I thought that for sure the people in Bali would refuse and become offended in mixing cultures, but the Bali musicians being interviewed made it sound like such a great experience to work with people from a whole different religion.
Everything about the Bali people was joyful, spiritual, and emphatically perfect in the way they played the instruments. Everything had a purpose; every design, every instruments, every musician. I loved how the Bali music incorporated not only good skills in playing the instruments, but good skills in teamwork as well. The Bali musicians have to have a good ear, and the ability to smoothly follow and lead each other.
This is something that western musicians are still trying to learn; staying together, and listening as an ensemble instead of as 30 different solosists.

Myrna said...

When I Ketut Gede Asnawa was at BYU a couple of years ago, he had us learn a 20 minute kecak segment, and he wanted a Christian hymn inserted in the middle of that Hindu tradition, which we did. Some of our audience thought it was a weird juxtaposition, but to the Balinese, it was just a way to tie the cultures together.

Scott said...

An Offering to the peace Gods, the documentary

I really liked this movie, I found it to be very in lightening on many of the thing that we are learning about Bali music and how it has grown and how it is today part of the lives of many people that aren’t from Bali but have grown to love this music and how it is part of their lives. It is amazing what one person can do to make a huge difference in the world. I see this professor form BYU as one of these great people that help to bridge the gap that is present form culture to culture. He has taken his love for the Bali people and their music and given students that great chance to grow and learn from it and be more rounded it there musical and cultural studies.
I really liked that the Bali people play as one. In this I mean that they aren’t playing a solo or a duet but that every one of them plays a very important part of the song making it so that you couldn’t play by yourself but you always have to play with a group to make a understandable sound. They respect everyone it the group as being important. I see that as being very amazing because I general you think of music in western orchestras we tend to see different instruments as being more important and that others. But in Bali they are all equally important.
I found it to be very intriguing that they the musicians in a gamelan don’t just focus on learn one instrument in particular but that they learn them all. For western music if you are way into music it is common to learn more than one instrument but for the general you only learn one so that you can perform. I gamelan they learn then all and can perform with them all! I’m sure that they just like those of us that know how to play more than one instrument have a preferred one but I still think that the idea of being able to play very instrument in the orchestra so well that I could perform in front of an ordinance to be very amazing!

Professor McKinney said...

Transmission
Video Report

Logan McKinney

Transmission would seem to be more than simply the communication of the notes. The Gospel chorister talked extensively of the need for the songs to be memorized by the performers--that even in their body language the audience must be convinced of what God has done. Even people who have the bare minimum of transmission (as in the Medieval Period of Musical Notation) still will look at pieces of art to determine positions of playing and what instruments would most likely have been involved. Even in our current mode of musical notation which usually gives as much detail as possible to the performer in terms of dynamics, fingerings, tempi, the composers often feel it necessary to give actual body cues, such as "bells up" for Horns.

The style of transmission in Japan bears a direct mark on many of the music teachers in Utah due to the common practice of the Suzuki method of string teaching. In Japan the teacher sits in front of the student, so that the student has a perfect example in front of them at all times. Most teachers in the western tradition will sit quietly as the student plays, making notes or preparing for corrections once the student has finished. My current cello teacher, who is deeply ingrained in the Suzuki style, will often mover her chair in front of me and say, "Alright, do what do," when I am learning a new technique. I find this method to be fairly difficult due to my lack of training in it; however, it is also very effective at getting the point across quickly and accurately.

In the Western Classical Tradition, the pianist attempted to explain the notation that cannot be written--phrasing. There is nothing more frustrating in music than phrasing and the extreme debates that rage about it. The pianist spoke of five-year-olds learning how to phrase. One of the my cellist friends always remembers when she was in high school and played the Haydn Cello Concerto in C Major. After finishing one of her classmates came up to her and said, "You played that Haydn as if it were Brahms," and walked away." Just this weekend I played a masterclasss with the Utah Symphony Principal Cellist, and he disagreed with my rhythmic interpretation of an Allemande by Bach. He went so far as to say, "You have lovely Romantic expressions; now fit them into the dance context." Often times we speak of this music as if we know, when in truth any attempt at regurgitating what the composer from the 1700s intended is only a guess. While the guess may be well educated and well researched, we often forget that a guess is all it really can be and ever will be.

Again, however, going back to the transmission of recordings as mentioned by the guitarist, we can oftentimes have a more accurate interpretation of what was wanted by the composer. The Shostokovich Cello Concerto was recorded by Rostropovich (for the whom the concerto was written) with Shostokovich supervising the recording. However, the Rostropovich edition of the concerto has certain markings that do not necessarily concur with the recording.

I really like how the pianist ended by stating that first a student must learn the music and then own it. Notation can only express so much. The performer often must fill in the missing notes.

Professor McKinney said...

An Offering to Please God

Logan McKinney

One of the most interesting points I felt the video offered was the description of the philosophy behind the creation of the instruments. The colors white and black to show the balance of good and evil, with red to symbolize power. Scriptures and fables are also carved into the sides to remind the players of pride and virtue. I thought how wonderful the story of the turtle was in relation to the function of the instrument. The turtle asks the birds to carry the stick so that he too might go with them as they fly to another location. When the birds are praised the turtle opens his mouth to correct and plummets to the earth. While creating music we might often tend to accept the praise for the work we have done while not acknowledging the origins of the world from which the music was most primevally divined. Their is a common theory in Hungary that the sol-fa system was developed in an effort to more accurately mimic the singing of birds and, subsequently, more accurately eat on a regular basis. Just as the turtle need not be worried about who gets credit, we might want to thank those who made the music possible in the first place. I also enjoyed the Balinese Navoo Sunstone to give the instruments a cultural balance, and greatly respected the BYU professor who wished to make sure that the Balinese would not find it offensive.

I considered the way Western instruments are usually manufactured. The West often tends towards efficacy over beauty. Amati began creating violins the way he did not so much as an attempt to make them more beautiful but to make them more effective as an extension of the human voice. While the scroll, pegs, tailpiece, and bow may often find greater ornamentation, the basic body of the instrument usually remains the same--varnished wood. However, this has not always been the case. Consider the Ex Vatican Stradivarius Cello, currently played by Wendy Sutter (http://www.wendysutter.com/instrument), which has a variety of images under the varnish.

In both cases it would seem that religion often influences a need to attach symbols to the instruments.

Professor McKinney said...

Texture

Logan McKinney

The Ganga is fascinating. It seems more like a communal shout or chant than an actual form of the music. However, to consider that weaving terms are used to describe the singing, the fascination heightens. True folk music which has not been influence by outside culture--which grew along side such common developments as weaving. It gives music a whole new perspective. Thinking of the parts weaving in and out to create a beautiful embroidery of sound. I especially loved how the people of Bosnia, or those who sing the Ganga, don't even conceive of the music as "parts making a whole." When asked to sing their part in the music, they can't do it. The part only makes musical sense or finds true musical identity when matched with the whole.

Contrast that with the Western Classical Tradition, in which it was mentioned that music can be seen as a giant conversation--each player needing to understand his or her role at all times within the greater picture. I once heard someone describe music as rhythm, melody, and harmony. He then proceeded to tell me, "it is our job to know which one we are providing at all times." Again, a very simplistic approach, which often leaves students constructing a hierarchy. The common idea of, "I am not melody so I don't matter in this context." How much more fulfilling in many ways would a weaving description and method of thought create. I am simply tapping on my cello for this part, but without me the music would be incomplete or torn.

The bor said...

Comment on the Timbre video:
Having had a lot of music classes already I knew a lot about most of this stuff already, so that makes it hard to write very much on it. The electronic device that they had was really interesting. It was like playing an air gutiar. Bill and Ted would have been proud.
There is an artist whose name is John Cage, and the guy is pretty crazy really. His music has a lot to do with timbre. Everything produces a sound and he arranges things in sounds instead of time and such.
I found it interesting how different cultures like different timbres. Take the voice section for example. Some cultures find sounds that we would find harsh, but in their culture it is beautiful. Indian music to me sounds very nasal, and I don't always like to listen to that kind of music just because of what I am use to.
I also really like the instruments that can make different timbres in themselves like the sax, the different drums, flutes, it just depends on how the musician plays the instument. Great example is the violion and fiddle. Same instrument, played different.

The bor said...

comments on texture video:
This video was pretty neat. I think that it is crazy how much differences there are between what people like and don't like. When you think about, or learn western music history you learn how things started with monophony and continued and got more and more complex, adding more melodies, and more texure to make the music much more interesting.
However with the flute and string instrument from Japan the texture was very simple, very direct and there was not a lot to try and sift through. I liked the irish jigs too. How there was one basic melody and the instruments just moved the melody in there own register and speed.
The part on gonga was crazy to me. there are moments where it sounds like music, and then there are other parts where it just sounds like noise. The fact that the music is improvised and each person just does their own thing kind of and it blends together is amazing.
Vocal textures are beautiful to me. Listening to the Austrailian composer was really neat. I love choral songs that start out together and then branch out into differnt parts and levels. It sounds so neat to me.
Oh, the part on steel drums was really neat. The sheer amount of instruments that they use is amazing! I know that you have orchestras that are that big, but the sound that you get when all of the instruments are similar is amazing.

jchoffman said...

John Hoffman
Video: Composers and Improvisers

The video on composers and improvisers was very interesting. Before watching the video I thought the two were completely different. After watching it, I think they are very similar. The main difference between them, in my opinion, is the timing of when they take place. Composing takes place before a performance, and improvising takes place during a performance. But, I think that when an artist is composing music, he/she is improvising, or making it up as they go. Compositions are preserved, either through memory or notation, so that they can be repeated over and over again. Western music is more reliant on composed, while Indian relies on improvision. Jazz music is more reliant on improvision, while Arabic uses both, but improvisation can be used more. In Rock-N-Roll music, both are important. In some ways I have a problem with improvising a Rock song. For instance, when I hear a song that I like on the radio, which was made in the studio as a recording, I really dislike when a live version of the song is played on the radio, or in concert, and the band/musicians changes the tune, or improvises it. I do not mind this for some songs, but some I really do mind. I have noticed, and it is just my opinion, that some music that is recorded in a studio is better than the live version. I may be in the minority with that opinion, but that is just what it is, an opinion. I do have a lot of respect for a musician who can improvise a song and still make it sound good. I think that takes a lot of talent. I thought the example in the video about the North Indian classical music and how the performers work with a small ampunt of precomposed music, with the bulk of the performance improvised. The musicians could have about 40 or 50 seconds worth of composed music in a two hour recital, so the majority of the recital is improvised. Some differences between composition and improvisation: comp. is written, improv is not; improv takes place in real time, comp does not; Improv is a group activity, comp is not. Improv is not completely free, it uses something that is known as a basis. Just because it is not written down does not mean it is a composition.

Unknown said...

Video 11 - Composers and Improvisers
I always wondered how improvising worked. I never really understood what it was until I watched this video. I had the Western View I thought improvisation was born out of nothing. I didn’t know what else to make of it. I always wondered how musicians could take music out of their brains and just play it, and have it make sense. I always thought it must take a musical genius to do that. I also didn’t think of compositions as more than just written music. This video has really opened my eyes to what composition and improvisation really are. What really surprised me is that improv isn’t just music that is made up on the spot. Improvisation is most often planned beforehand, in one way or another. Jazz musicians, for example, are aware of the composed piece, what key it is in, the time signature and the harmonic structure but they must improvise around the melody. “You have to know where you’re at and where you’re getting,” says one jazz musician on the video. That’s one thing I never understood about improvising is how the musician knows that their improvisation makes sense, so I now understand that they use a structure of the piece as a foundation. Improvisation is not completely free, it uses something that is a known basis. I was also surprised about what I learned about composition. The processes of improvisation and composition are not much different. In fact, one composer on the video said: composition is really just written improvisation. The composer can make things up as he goes, and that’s not much different from improvisation. The biggest difference between the two is composition takes place before the performance while improvisation takes place during the performance.

james said...

James Fairbank
Video report
Sound, music, and the environment
I watched the video on sound, music, and the environment and I thought it was very interesting. The part that really stuck out to me during this video was when the old Asian man said,” music is like food. Everyone needs food, but everyone is picky about the kind of food they have.” I thought this was very true. In my experience of living in New York there is a wide spread variety of music. I was able to relate to this because in high school you see the cliques of people based on a couple of things and one of those reasons are on what type of music you listen to. Another reason why I found this statement to be interesting is because I love food. I love everything about food, but I am very picky about my food and it made me think that I am very picky about my music I listen too. So it made me think that if someone isn’t really picky about things that their taste generally seems to be less picky and they are open to do many things, in this case, listen to many types of music. None the less, this video was full of many facts that I thought were interesting but this is the one fact that made me think during the whole video.

Anonymous said...

Gateway to Rhythm
I can’t remember the last name of the two musicians but this video with John And Selva will always stick out in my mind. When the video first started I didn’t know what to think. It was so different and weird in my eyes I really couldn’t comprehend. I just didn’t understand how you could replace notes with words, because it seemed like learning the notes would be easier. And the combination of the Ta or Taka seemed like it would be harder to do. And because I am surrounded by western music my whole life, the Konokol was too much for me to handle. I will be honest when they did the first come practices with Selva, I laughed because it sounded like straight gibberish. But as the video went on it started to make sense to me. Even though the Indian words didn’t fit to every note perfectly, it did in fact fit to the grouping of notes. When he hit sixteenth notes I could feel my eyes go big with amazement! Selva said the words so fast and it was hard to believe he wasn’t get all tongue-tied.
As the practices went on the rhythms became complex and the words did as well. And I sat there thinking to myself just how long did it take this man to learn all this. Selva was doing the Konokol groupings with such ease, like it was nothing to him. But I had to remind myself not everyone learns music like I have and that he had most likely been learning that his whole life. One thing I couldn’t get even at the very end was when John would turn Konokol into notes on the guitar. In my mind I couldn’t figure out how in the world the two sounded remotely together. I don’t know, maybe it was just me. I would rather hear it performed orally than listening to someone play it on the guitar.
I loved learning about the Konokol and am very thankful for the opportunity to get to listen to someone like Selva perform it. It makes western music seem so limited in my eyes now.

Myrna said...

Posting for Ashley: Bringing the music of Bali to BYU


First can I start by saying that I am very jealous of the BYU students because they have the opportunity to get to learn how to play these beautiful instruments from Bali. I mean when you think of music classes in school you think orchestra or band, right? Because that is what comes to my mind when I think of it. But it is the coolest thing ever when a school offers a class like this that opens student’s eyes by putting instruments in front of them that they have never played before and is from a different country.

Now I’m sure that it takes quite some time to make a violin or cello but some instruments that are made for Gamelan music takes up to 6 months to make. Why it takes so long is because of the complex and beautiful carvings on the instruments. I loved watching has the man made these design, it seems so tidiest. It is said that they do these carving for a reason, that by putting designs on them and have bright colors that it leaves no room for evil spirits or demons to disrupt the instrument. They treat their instruments as if they were people. They show a lot of respect by not stepping over the instrument. So it makes sense that they would put these carving on the instruments to keep them rid of demons. It was cool to me that every instrument has their own carvings on the side.

Another thing that I liked to learn about was how they tuned their instruments. Tuning took some time and an eye that knew what they were doing. I thought to myself if I ever had a chance to tune an instrument like that it would be a sure thing that I would mess it up, even if I had training to do so. I mean I have problems to this day tuning my violin. I thought the fact that they made a gemalan set for the BYU music department and that they even put on some LDS carvings that mean something to us. You would think that they wouldn’t ever put something on their instruments besides their religious stories.

Unknown said...

Video report 4
I thought the girl at the beging was awesome. I only wish I was half as good as her. I thought it was kind of cool how the africans would just start a beat and if others liked they would get there pots and pans and join in. I wish it was that way here, how awesome would that be. I thought it was also cool to see how the kids of bali started at suck a young age. I really liked how the jazz guy was saying that even though he was technacaly self thought he really wasent. He had all his bands and musicians he loved and lisoned to that helped him learn. I loved seeing some of the people playing on this video. They are insain! I would have loved to learn how to play some of that really old music and kind of get the opertunity to use what ever instruments. I thought that it intresting how they really did'nt care what instruments were used, just cared about what was being played. I really liked the Video alot I really learnd tons and it was fun to watch.

Unknown said...

Video 7
I've never really never thought about how many different sounds we can get out of our insturments. It really is amazing. It is also how we can make it all work to gether. It was awesome when they showed all the different sounds of the instruments playing the same note. The tamber is also amazing, I love the theory behind it. It is cool how they create the sound by over laping sounds to get that crazy sound. I also liked the part where they stared talking about the nae. It looks like there is so much work going in to making the nae. It is also just a beuatiful instrument. Another part i liked was the that japanez singing. they really have to strech there voice in order to sing like they do. I was amazing to see how many instruments that guy withe the long thick hair. I thought this video was cool because all the instruments they show you in this video.

Unknown said...

Video 8
I love Texture, be it one or two insturment of one million. I love hearing the verietys of music. It's hard to just lison to one type all the time, I love the verietys. I like to asosiate it with life. you can emagon what it would be like if the same thing happend to use every day. It would get old after a while, even if you life was exciting. we need that veriety of like to keep us intrested. we need adventure, love, relacsation, callenge, fun, and even the said days. Its the exact same way with texture i feel, I need the different types of music and music paces to keep me intrested, or else i would get board of music. Thats just how I feel about it, I don't know if any of you agree with me but that what I think.

Unknown said...

Video 11
I love composing a song. Just locking my self in a room with nothing but me, my guitar, piano, and drums, and just write a song for the whole day. That is so fun to me and it is the best way to pass the time to. Seeing some of these violen player play with such grace and beuty, really makes me want to pick up the violin again and learn how to play that damn thing. I really have respect with the violensts. It is really a lot harder than it looks to play a violin. The Arabic music they played in the video was increadable! That guy was amazing and it was cool how he was improing that whole thing basically.It was also crazy that they never repeat the same melody. Again I wish I was half as good as him. I loved this video. It was awesome seeing people compose there music.

Unknown said...

video 6
Holy crap that guy at the begining singing really low was crazy. That was some to the low sing I have ever sing. I thought the way the Arobic guy discribed melody was good. "Notes that are in love with eachother. He is right because we two people are truly in love they work together and are beuataful. That is what you want you song to be like. It needs to work together. In this video there wasent to many things I learnd in this video. I did like the music they picked, for exsample motzart. It was a good video though.

Unknown said...

Video 9
Harmany is so improtant. Like that guy said at the beginging. You have a awesome bowl of pasta, which is the melody, then you have the soace on top which is the harmany. If musicians dont harmanize there music it is really bad. I am sorry the A tone music or what ever it was after the compossers hit the top with harmany is bad. It really hurts my ears. I normally don't like calling any music noise, but that was absolut trash. Again there wasent to much I learn in this video, a lot of these videos kind of go over the same thing. I did like the music again though.

Unknown said...

The Gateway to Rhythm
This video was Awesome. All the words they say that stand for all the diferent counts we use. It's cool that you don't need drums or anything instruments. I can't believe that they can get up to 1\36 count. That is rediculuse. I thought it was cool how young the kids learn it. If you really want to learn something the best way to do it is to learn young. I have a hard time keeping the beat with my hands and saying all that stuff at the same time. Ithis not easy. The rest of the video was kind of repetative I thought, even though the stuff they do gets harder every time its all kind of the same. I liked the movie a lot.

Unknown said...

Amanda Skinner
Video 6 report Melody
This video has opened my eyes to the importance of melody and what it means in a song. I really liked how the Arabic musician Shaheen put it: “a melody is a series of notes that are in love with each other.” Melody is considered the most important part of a song; it is what makes the song memorable and meaningful. Melody makes the words sing, and song makes it possible to feel a thought. Melodies vary in different parts of the world depending on the musical rules of that culture. We cannot pick out any kind of series of notes and call it a melody. In order to make melodies we need to follow rules that apply to that culture. Western, Arabic, Indian, and Irish style music all have different kinds of rules.
Western style usually build melodies within major or minor scales. Variations are used within those scales to create different patterns and intervals, those intervals are arranged to create a pattern of notes and rhythm breathes life into that pattern of notes. Often melodies are created by building on one single idea, putting that idea into variations and contrasting that idea with a completely new one.
Arabic classical music have musical rules called Maqam which is a series of notes meant to be played in a certain pattern. Every maqam has a mood to it, and would be played in certain times of day. Arabic music also uses a concept called microtones, tones in between tones. Microtones sound like a note is being played out of tune, but it is not. The quality of the tone is the same.
North Indian music has rules similar to maqam, but their rules are called raga. Indian music has hundreds of ragas, that act as a recipe for the melody of a song. Every melody in Indian music most conform to one raga or another, no one can just make up a melody out of any series of notes. Each raga has many rules to it, but the main ones are each one has chosen notes in an octave going up or going down in particular patterns, and one dominant note. Ornamentation gives life to the raga and a unique style.