I found it to be so interesting that in this class of music that they fill that empty space is area in which corruption can happen and that evil spirits can poses it. I had wondered why they had such elaborate carvings on their instruments after seeing them on the trip to BYU. I had just imagined that the culture was very artistic and like to show off their skills with wood and art. But after all that I have learned I see that it is something very close to them as instrument makers. I really think it is amazing how religious they are and how this religion is part of the instrument itself and its creation. I really liked that they also respected the instrument. Their feeling of reverence towards the instrument itself is very intriguing and fascinating. In our culture we give reverence to the musician that plays but with them the musician isn’t important, it is the instrument that is and they give respect to it and the amazing sound that it makes.
Jason, sent to me via e-mail: Through this whole experience with Gamelan, listening to the different instruments, seeing how they’re played, and getting to know the culture behind Gamelan I have come out of this learning experience so enriched by it. I was utmost impressed with the true ensemble exists in this type of music. But, not only the music, but the entire culture as well.
One impression I got during this experience was how I wished that our culture here in the United States, from a cultural standpoint, could live like that! The harmony that seems to permeate the Balinese culture because of this sense of community is astounding to me. It is so wonderful to witness such unity. As well, despite the uneven pitches that exist in Gamelan music, I found myself, the longer I listened to it, the more my ear got used to it and it started to have a very peaceful effect on me. The music was calming. I could really understand why this music is so sacred to the Balinese people.
I also found interesting was the fact that how each instrument was distinct and unique, and that it had to be played within a certain group, compared with western music. The specialty skill one needs to play instruments such as these is mind blowing to me. I truly admire anyone that can play these instruments! I am so glad we took the time to discover this type of music and this culture.
I thought it was interesting that they held a ceremony before the concert to ward away evil. It is remarkable to this day they hold this ceremony. The whole concert is dedicated to ward away evil and fill the empty void with music. Its cool that they decorated their instruments to convey beauty and keep evil away from harming anyone. I thought it was interesting for dancers to move in such a detail way. Also they teach this kind of dancing very young.
The way they though is kind of odd, tuning each instruments different that they almost sound good. The reason for this is that they tune them out of tune from each other. Also they have to know know the correct time to stop and or keep playing at the correct moment and let others play.
I found it weird at first how they tune their instruments, but then I noticed how great the sound came out of it, even if in my ears, they were "out of tune". Just knowing that a particular section is tuned to a certain pitch and the other sections are tuned in their own unique pitch is interesting. Not only I found that Hindu was a major part in their culture, but I found it interesting that the Hindu religion was an important to the Balinese music as well. I like it how not only the instruments are nicely crafted for tuning, but also the designs the instruments were given. The idea to make them sound the same AND look the same is a great idea. It gives the audience something else to look at while they hear their music being played. It is also great that they keep the westerners away who don't know how to give proper respect to the playing area and instruments. They really like it to keep things sacred.
Balinese Gamelan- I found Balinese Gamelan music very fascinating. I never knew instruments that were out of tune could sound so beautiful, especially when played with many other instruments in an ensemble. The shimmering sound that is produced as a result is mesmerizing. The cooperation in gamelan music is also fascinating. Their culture is perfectly reflected in their music. They strongly believe in cooperation and balance. Even when it comes to who’s rice fields can grow. In a Balinese village, the villagers figure out where the water will flood next so those people can prepare to plant their rice fields, while other people must wait to plant their rice fields until the water comes to them, so everyone can eventually get to plant their rice and have food for themselves. This cooperation is seen in their Balinese Gamelan. Each player has their own part, and if one player loses their place or forgets where they are, they will throw everyone else off. What makes it even more difficult, gamelan music is seldom performed with sheet music, and most often by memory. The performers must know the music like the back of their hand, and know other parts on other instruments as well. They all must be able to play the instruments as well as their own. All parts of Gamelan music come together as a cohesive whole. All the instruments in the Gamelan shine, and not one is just for back up music like what is common in Western music. Soloists are rare, and the instruments are the stars rather than the musicians that play them.
I think it is really interesting how the people view the instruments and the music. The instruments are sacred and very special. They are to be treated with respect. It is a privilege for a person to get to display the beauty of the instrument. Gamelan players do not try to stand out or have solos. This is very different than Western music. Religious differences between Java and Bali can be seen in their music. Javanese Gamelan tends to be quieter and more improvisational because Islam “officially disapproves of music.” I think it is amazing that none of their music is notated. I’m surprised that it has been preserved so well. The instruments themselves, are very beautifully crafted and each set of gamelan instruments are tuned to each other but will not mix with other groups of instruments. They tune their notes slightly off to create a shimmery sound.
I think it is very interesting how different cultures treat pitches differently. Tuning the actual instruments ais different. In Java, instruments are tuned slightly different to create a beat or shimmery sound. In western music, we try to avoid the beats. We try to match exactly the tuning note. I think it is interesting that A 440 is supposedly our standard but often orchestras will tune to 442. Even harmonies are different in different cultures. In western music, our ears are accustom to consonant sounds. In more recent times exploration of dissonance has become more common but in other cultures dissonance in tone clusters is common. Some cultures use microtones and quarter tones more commonly than western music. The way our modern piano is tuned has locked us into using half steps and whole steps. Music can be thought of vertically (harmonies) or horizontally (Melodies).
By reading this chapter I learned what pitch actually is. I never really had to think about it until now. I understand it to be the foundation for both melody and harmony. Names are given to pitches as an aid to memory, using syllables, numbers, or letters. The syllables, which have been used in Euoropean music since 1600 are: do, re, mi fa, so, la, ti, and do. I actually learned this long ago from watching "The Sound of Music." Setting the pitch on an instrument, for example the metallophone, is done by the person who constructs the instrument, by scraping or filing away different parts of the bar.
The distinction between orchestra and gamelan I found interesting. The fact that orchestras have specific instruments that need to be there, else it is not considered an orchestra, and gamelans do not have requirements is somewhat superising. I know that there are specifics to being in an orchestra, for example I could not play in my high school orch because I played the sax. Not an instrument that they want honking in the middle of a concerto. But then I thought about bands. There are jazz bands, marching bands, rock bands, Ryan Shupe and the “rubber band”. So there are American equivalents to the gamelans. It is very remarkable to me that the gamelans do not have a central tuning focus. In a way it is really cool, and on the other hand it is very strange and not practical. It brings the players together and unites them, makes them loyal to that specific gamelan. But at the same time if different gamelans want to play together they can’t. I love how everything is interconnected in gamelan music. From the instruments, to the players, the community, just the whole idea of them is togetherness. Koteken is really neat. I like how everything interlocks with each other to make a giant whole. The idea that one player alone cannot make an entire melody ring true, and that all instruments are interdependant is a good way to bring everyone together. I like it!!
I really enjoyed learning about pitch. By reading this i was better able to see how pitch is used in melody and also in harmony. Melody is the selection of pitches in sucession. Harmony is what you hear overall or the pitches heard simultaneously. I also enjoyed learning how some intruments the pitch is fixed and on others it is set by the people. In the chapter i was also able to learn about scales and tones. Overall i really enjoyed reading this chapter. I was able to learn alot of new and interesting things and better understand music.
I was so very fascinated about how different cultures tune their instruments. Notation (the language of pitch) is also very different between different cultures.
I never really thought about it before how pitch can inform an entire musical piece. But what I found really fascinating in the reading was how many different approaches there are as well to setting pitches.
Teaching pitches as well was a fascinating part of the chapter. And the idea of putting letters to different pitches made me giggle a bit. We've all grown up with Do Re Mi from "The Sound of Music." But now, as an adult, and particularly after reading this chapter, I really can see what a great way it is to teach music. It is so simply put!
Chapter 4-pitch Pitch varies among cultures in many different ways depending how the culture interprets that pitch. Mode varies with cultures also. Modes refer to mood. The European system puts major scales as a happy mood and minor as a sad mood. Dissonance and consonance also depend on certain intervals. Microtones, 24 selections of pitches in a selection 7 pitch scale, are also used by some cultures. We need to remember that our music is not necessarily the right kind of music, and music can have the same concepts but within a different context. Some cultures don’t think of happy or sad in the context of major or minor as the European system does, but they think of fast or slow as connotating a mode. Also while the European system interprets major and minor seconds as dissonant, Bulgarian women interpret them as consonant or pleasant and smooth. Culture plays a huge role in how we hear music.
Chapter 4. Pitch is the fundamental element in both melody and harmony. Pitch is nothing more than a tone. When tones are put together they create a scale which in turn creates music. In the book Ms. Wade says “harmony can be defined as pitches heard simultaneously.” I would agree with what she says, but add that those pitches must flow together and blend for those pitches to create beautiful harmony. Such as a river flows. The tones that nature creates herself always seem to be in harmony with each other. I enjoyed learning and reading about Solfege’s. I loved seeing them put into a song and in song form. The Sound of Music illustrates this point wonderfully. It is actually my favorite song from the entire movie. I used to play the trumpet many years ago, and when I was learning we used a different form of Solfege. Instead of using letters we used numbers to indicate which valve we were to push down to play the right note and at the right pitch. Pitches are usually set during the construction phase of instrument building. However this is not always the case. Many times a musician will alter the pitch of their instrument to suit the music that they are playing. The placement of pitch is taken from the traditions of the area in which the music is being played. A pitch setting from China will not be at the same pitch level as music from the Andes mountain region. They are made of different materials therefore they will have differing pitches. I have found the study of pitches to be a wonderful learning opportunity that I now understand better after having matured some and can appreciate them more. It is amazing to see the different pitches from different cultures and the different way that pitch is classified. I believe that I have a better understanding for pitch and will listen better to the music that I enjoy for the harmony of those pitches. I will also listen to the harmony of pitches that are nature to see how they all connect.
Ch four I thought this was a very interesting chapter about pitch. Pitch is how low or high a sound is. It makes up the world we live in Everything has a pitch - the sounds we hear every day like a car going down the street or the sweet sound of a muscle car reving its engine. In musical terms, “pitch is a fundamental element in both melody and harmony. Melody is a selction of pitches in succession.” It is what gives the melody that catchy feeling that you can never get out of your head. Harmony is pitches that are played at the same time. It is the underlining notes or sound that just makes everything flow. It is interesting to see how each culture uses pitches and tones in their own way. For example, when we play a musical intrument, we want each instrument to play the same note or one that harmonizes with every other instrument in the group. Unless the purpose of the musical piece is to hurt our ears or make us grind our teeth, we want to have no conflicting noises. But in Gamelan music, they purposely tune every instrument just slightly off eachother to make a wavy, intersecting sound that we in our culture, have a hard time tolerating. Whether it is the discordant sounds of Gamelan music, the sweet sounds of a ’67 Mustang reving its engine, or the harmonic pieces of Mozart and Rachmaninov; the differences and blending of pitches in our music make what we hear communicate the thoughts and feelings of the composer. Without it, music would cease to be what it is - amazing.
Chapter 4 talks about tuning in different cultures. While one country has the instrument tuned to have zero fault in it another culture would have it slightly out of tune to have a different pitch. Not only that but they actually sound good. Also how different styles of music will tune to specific pitches. It makes it pleasing to the ear.
Chapter 4 is probably my favorite chapter because it talks about how differing cultures have different pitches and that not every sound has to be the same.
Ch. 5, Thinking About Structure: Different cultures and countries have different forms of structure for their pieces, and that is one of the things that make their music unique. The chapter discussed the multiple definitions of improvisation and composition, and I thought it interesting that for some cultures, their improvising is totally free; without some kind of rhythmic, or melodic foundation to build upon. The chapter also talked about arrangements of songs, and how composers could rearrange a song just by changing the structure, or order of events. For example, there could a popular song that is usually slow and smooth, but a remix of the same song, is viewed totally different if it starts out with a big bang! This could either change that particular song for the better, or for the worse, depending on the audience the original, or remix was meant for. I also liked the fact that a song style from a specific culture, will always have the same structure: the chapter gave an example of the North Indian instrumental structure in that it starts out with a main melody line at a slow tempo, then adds rhythmic flavor as the tempo speeds up. This just proves to show us that how the music is structured and put together, is what makes it special to each particular culture.
Chapter 5- Structure I find it fascinating how many different musical structures there are in the world. I found it very interesting how music can be performed so differently among cultures. In Middle Eastern improvised music, the musician presents a musical idea to an audience and will either prolong that idea according to the audiences reaction or will not prolong it. The audience is very interactive with the performers. If they like something they will let the performers know through gesturing or calling out any number of traditional phrases. In Balinese dalang shadow puppet performances the interaction of the master puppeteer with the musicians shapes what kind of music will be played, depending on what the puppeteer wishes to have. He will give cues to the musicians on what to play. East Arab aesthetic feedback system is much different from some European systems which are essentially sit still, and be silent until the end of the performance. Essentially Western art practices do not shape the performance as the Balinese and Arab practices may.
The chapter on structure was interesting in a couple of different ways. The section about improvising and composing was interesting how it highlighted the misconceptions about the two. One is that improvisation is "free" and that the music being created during a performance is not based on anything preexisting. Rather the musician may base the performance on something that already exists, like ensemble relationships, or rhythym patterns. Structure also varies in different cultures. It is used to give the music an identity unique to the culture. The gamelan music we studied is a very good example of this.
I really enjoyed reading chapter five. In this chapter i learned what improvising and composing are. In improvising it is important to note that music is created during the performance and is not based on anything that is already preexisting. Composing and Improvising are alot alike. Many people tend to think that composing means that nothing is being created only performed. We think that for something to be created it needs to be improvised. In the book it talked about how this is not always true because in some cultures the music isn't even written down. It also talked about how in some cultures it is important to ease into the music. To start with just a couple of instruments at a time until finally they are all playing together. It also talked about the different types of forms of playing such as the North India form, Sonata form, and others. In the chapter it talked about the importance of the music telling the story. The story that the music tells is as important as the music itself. I really enjoyed reading this chapter and was able to learn alot of new things.
Chapter 6- I never knew how many issues there were surrounding music. Authenticity is a very interesting issue that I never really thought about. How do we figure out if something really is authentic or not? Many different types of music are more acculturated then we think. Flamenco music that we may assume originated in spain, actually has many different types of influences in the singing an dance styles in Flamenco, including Punjabi singing in India, and Jewish synagogue chants. The poverty of a country shapes what their music is like; lack of resources, poor living conditions, and little income all affect their music. If the people don’t have a lot of money to buy well crafted instruments, they will have to use the available resources around them, whatever they are. The Central Africa Republic is an example of this. The only instruments they can afford is handmade instruments made from what little resources there are around them. They are also a people who always must focus on survival, and this affects their music as well. They don’t have a lot of movement in their dancing and they have simple music, so they can save their energy for survival.
I now have a better understanding of all the issues that surround music. The problem that it states in the book is that nothing is truly global, consumed, produced or understood in the same way. Everyone has different opinions and this creates many issues in music. It talks about the issue about what is world music? Really many things could be considered world music. Should it just be the music that is foreign or are the musicians that play rock just mainstream? In the chapter it also talked about the different types of identities. There are many different types of identities throughout the world. Music is the same ways. There are a lot of different identities and it is hard to identify each one. Another issue is authenticity. Who came up with the music and who does it belong to? I really enjoyed reading this chapter and was able to learn a lot. I didn't realize all the issues in music and now I have a better understanding.
These are probably too late to turn in, but I'm doing it anyways...
Ch 4-Thinking about Pitch I never saw Harmony and Melody before how they explained, as in Melody being a horizontal figure of pitch and Harmony being a vertical figure of pitch. Instruments that have a fixed pitch are usually manufactured into this standard, but the instrumentalists without the fixed pitch have the job to adjust its pitch. The notes are usually apart by whole steps or half steps as they are called intervals. The spaces between notes also get higher as the interval changes as in C to D is a whole step (major 2nd) and C to F is 2 wholes and a half (major 4th). There are also intervals smaller than the half step. Some of them are called microtones and others are called quartertones. None of these fit in the Western scales in music, but usually featured in Arab music, which is based on a theory of having pitches in an octave.
CH 5-Thinking About Structuring There are 2 kinds of structures in music. One of them is to improvise and the other one is composition. The improvising part is being completely free in doing anything that isn't based in anything preexisting. The composition is based on a given music. It can also be called improvising, but it's not completely free because of the given music prior to that, as it is called composition for that matter. Usually, a composition is replayable, unlike improvising, it's basically a solo that would most likely not be played again, unless if intended to. In some places, like in Indonesia, there are people called dalang, which is a puppeteer. He sings cues to the musicians and play songs that are appropriate to the scene. The musicians have a written piece of music to play, but they don't know when to play it. I thought that idea was pretty cool.
This chapter was very interesting. I had never thought before that improvisation could be considered composition before. But it makes sense. In improvisation, composition takes place during a performance, regular composing takes place before a performance. This brings me back to the many jazz concerts I have enjoyed and now after reading this chapter I now have a deeper understanding and appreciation for what they do. The contrasting ways that different countries as well, structure their music I also found fascinating. Also I appreciated the time the author took in this chapter on Context and why composers structure their compositions the way they do. Particularly I was fascinated by vocal pieces. I had never really thought about how composers put certain lyrics on high notes and others on low ones, and how they compose the music to emphasize certain lyrics. Basically, this all has to do with context. This chapter really opened up my eyes to the endless possibilities of structure and how it can be manipulated, as well as how culture can play a significant role in the structure of music of that specific culture.
The things I want to focus on in this report, that really stood out for me in this chapter are the issues of political, authenticity and culture. I had never really thought about how the politics of a nation could be an issue with the music of that specific nation. I am amazed throughout history how music sometimes has been underground in oppressive regimes like in Afghanistan under the rule of the Taliban. Even the folk music specific to a nation can be influenced politically. How communism in China has influenced the music greatly because of its rigid practices and its strict governance over anything that can be construed as subversive. Culture I already was aware as an issue in music but as I am preparing for my part in the final project I’m doing on Navajo music I am fascinated by how music is so deeply rooted in this culture. Traditions are passed down from generation to generation and how it is treated as sacred! You can see culturally how bluegrass music was influenced. The simplicity of the people really translates into that particular style of music. Finally, the issue of authenticity; I can really see now how this can become an issue with music. Particularly with oral traditions passed down, it is important that a certain amount of authenticity be maintained, and how easily it might not be maintained as it passes down through the generations. Copyright issues play a big factor in this as well. This chapter reminded me recently of an issue with the new Michael Jackson CD coming out early next year, and how a certain song that was supposed to be hidden one, experts are now saying doesn’t sound like him. I listened to it on the radio and I agree. So authenticity is a really big issue. This chapter I enjoyed the most. It really covered so many things I had never really thought much about.
Chapter 6: Thinking About Issues As we discussed in class, there are many issues and ways that cultures, and music can be either lost, or refined around the world. The book gives several examples, such as boundries, religions, gender, and believe it or not, I think a lot has to do with what type/style of music surrounding countries are listening to. The author gives the example of when she traveled to Tahiti (French Polynesia) the youth there wanted to listen to the typical American music; rock and roll, hip-hop, etc. The music of Tahiti still stays on pretty prevalent, but it is being forced to accommodate western music as well. I think that this could provide good issues, and bad. It is good, in the fact that the youth and people around the world are expanding their horizons when it comes to a variety of music. It is bad, in that cultures are morphing, and a lot of them are taking their ancient music, and modernizing them to make them more attractive to the ears of people today. Okay, this is not necessarily a bad thing, but it does make one wonder; how many cultures have changed because of the influence of surrounding countries? How many ancient styles of music were lost because the music played has to match what the people want to listen to today?
Chapter 4 I found it interesting how so many different cultures look at pitch completly different. They each have their own take on what is pleasing, and what is not. I find it amazing how many different systems there are for assigning pitch. In western music we seem to leave out a lot of things that could make our music more interesting. I think that is why I like electronic music so much, it opens pitches that you would not normally have in westen music. The bali instruments still facinate me, how they are tuned in pairs and work in unison with each other to produce slight waves in the pitch that you hear. The quality of instruments avalible seem to have a fair bit to do with the pitches that are avalible for a culture, thus influencing the scales, and music itself, how it is put together. It makes perfect sense to me because I read music, but the way they describe harmony in the book is very visual, the horizontal and vertical idea. LIke I said it makes perfect sense I just don't think I have thought of it that way before.
The whole cd the you tube clip was linked to is really good about Ashley Macisaac. The Irish group might find it interesting to listen to, especially the fiddle player, sorry I forgot your name, Anali maybe. Sorry.
Chapter 5 The battle between composing and inprovisation is an interesting one. I can understand how ethnomusicologists think that some imporvisation is composing, and how composing is really just a vastly slowed down process of improv. I agree with both ideas. I think I agree more that improv can be a form of composition because to be able to do imporv you have to know the rules, scales, and information that you would need to know to compose a piece. I find that strophic compositions are easier to do than are through compositions. They also add to being able to recall the song better and eaiser. Rondo form adds a little bit to the rememberablity (new word of the day) of a song. If you can repeat the same kind of thing over and over it lends to a sense of unity to the piece. The written music can seem to loose a little of it's appeal after awhile because it is played the same way over and over. however for evaluation purposes, and playablity purposes this lends itself nicly. It also makes it so everyone can play it not just those that are educated in the way of music. If you like rock music it gives a nice exapmle to how you can blend improv and composition. Bands come up with the songs that they record and sell, but if you go to a concert you see them improv almost all the time. It makes it exciting to go to concerts because you know you are going to hear somthing new.
Chapter 6 As an American I am very national, very proud and happy to be an American. I think that many other nations are the same way. They have their style of music and that is what they think about, they could care less about others around them. After all the world music is just noise anyway. This kind of thinking is sad because one of the neatest things in the world is hearing a song you know well, but hearing it in a new way. A pop song played on the bagpipes with a little bit of an Irish twist on it is neat. The issue of gender is a hard one to wrap my brain around now a days. It seems that it would not be an issue anymore, but it obviously is. In a lot of nations women are forbidden to perform types of music. This is sad because of the different textures, touches and emotions women can breath into music. Having that social status is an issue too. The religious aspects of music hit home to me a lot. I am a very religious person, and as such I miss out of some of the different musics of the world. If it does not sit well with my beliefs and values I tend to ignore that kind of music. I try and still keep an open mind and not shun generes, but rather song. I know that this is not so with others. Look historically at how great a role churches have played in music. In western music it is huge, in all nations it has roots there. If the music does not meet up to a certain standard of morality, or values in many cultures it is shuned or obliterated, or stopped from progressing. An example there is a fiddle player from Scotland who as the story goes actually got kicked out of the contry for (desecrating) traditional Scotish songs, of course that is just the story I have heard, so don't quote me on it:^). You should look him up his name is Ashley Macisaac, and he is increadible. Here is a link for ya if you choose to look him up. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HGe9PLC8SL0
Just FYI: Ashley MacIsaac is Canadian, from Cape Breton Island, which is an enclave of celtic music. Super-good musicians seem to grow up on that island!
Pitch is a element that is in both melody and harmony that makes it fundamental. Pitch can be in simple terms as tones, and get more complex to the formation of intervals and scales. Pitch although known to be an element for melody(which is thinking horizontally) and for harmony(which is thinking vertical) which means that all notes in music are from left to right and start from the top of a page and go to the bottom. Pitch to some people is the different between the highness and lowness of music. This shows how all music has high pitched sounds that can hurt our ears, example is like the screeching of tires. And can also be a very low pitch that is easy on us which is like a roar from a motorcycle engine. Without the difference in pitches in a song or piece of music, we would get bored with the repetition of a song. This would create no great music to us and all would seem the same. Pitch is a must to all music around the world. If we use music without pitch like I said it would be boring and no one would care to create new music or listen because all is the same.
James Fairbank Chapter report 5 In the thinking musically book, in the chapter thinking about structure the thing that stood out to me was the improvising and composing. This stood out to me because I hold improvisation very close to me. I loved to improvise all the time. Improvisation is defined in the book as,” the process of interweaving musical material that is given with material that is newly created even as one listens. This is closely associated with composing. One example of this is typically in the song April in Paris by the Count Basie orchestra they have a solo that was improvised when making it by Thad Jones. That solo was so popular to the song that the improvisation was composed into what the song is today. This is a prime example of how improvisation can be tied into composing. I also learned in this chapter that when a person is improvising its sort of their way of telling a story to the audience. For example when one improvises the way you flow with the music would be to that of how a story is told. A story could be the three pigs. When the pigs are scared you accent more on the notes and when they are all safe in the brick house you would use some slurs to represent that. When the big bad wolf tries to blow the house down you could throw in some crescendos and decrescendos. That is how I would describe telling a story with the improvisation.
The balinese Gamelan is awesome! I absolutly love there style and they way there music sounds. I this is crazy how much time they put into their insruments, what was it like 3 mounths to tune there instruments. The way they tune them is cool to, they tune the other insruments a half a note off from the other so that you get that crazy sound out of them. The design of the instruments is amazing to. it must take them forever to do it. I also thought it was cool that each of the carvings accually have a story to them. They are truly amazing down in bali. It is also amazing how many instruments are in the gamelan. there are tones. This was defenetly one of my favorite things I have learnd this year.
I really thought it to be interesting that as you travel form one culture to another you find that the idea a correct pitch changes. In western music we want all of the instrument to be tuned exactly the same thus giving It what we claim to be harmony but if you look at bale music they have every instrument tuned just off of each other so that you can hear the conflicting waves of sound that give it a wobbly sound. I found it to be very funny that we always try to tune to A or to 440 but that we as human can’t have a perfect pitch but that even the best of the western musicians will tune to 442 over 440. Another interesting difference that is found throughout the world is how we tune a note. We in western music have a set scale of notes no more no less and if you play out of this note you are considered out of tune. This is not so in other coulters of the world where they have usable note in-between out have and quarter notes giving them a larger rage of usable tones and give them to us a out of tune sound
I think that the structure of music is something very individual to every culture. There are so many different ways to compose music. We being raised in the western music form find it to be the clearest and simplest to understand. With it we are able to write music from all over the world in a way that it can be played and understand by us. But if we look at the forms of composition from say Japan we don’t find exactly notes but more of how to play the song. It tends to be longer and more detailed in how you should play it but in western music not so much so. But that is something I love! We have the great opportunity to put out personality into the music that we play. We can play the music exactly how it is written but that is just playing notes to me, it is in the moment that we take the music can make it part of us and actually feel it in us it that we are truly able to make it alive and free. This isn’t as possible in other cultures music because they are tolled exactly what to do.
Ch. 4 Thinking about pitch I thought it was really cool to learn about how other cultures tuned their instruments. Some would tune theirs to sound slightly off in order to create a shimmery sound when played. And at first when I heard it, the sound bothered me because I wasn’t used to it and it sounded off to me. But when I learned about them more I was able to really listen for the shimmer affect that they were going for.
Before reading this chapter I never knew about a lot of the terms that were talked about. For example terms like chord progression, heterophony or diatonic scales. But know I know that chord progression is a sequence of chords. A heterophony is when multiple musicians perform one melody, but each musician might render the melody differently. And that diatonic scales are arrangements of half steps and whole steps.
Also when reading about teaching pitches, thought back to the Sound of Music movie and realized back when I would watch it has a child that I was actually being taught pitches without even knowing it. It cool how a simple song like that forever sticks with you as you grow up, and not realizing that you something about music even if you never spent a day in your life in class being taught it.
Ch. 5 Thinking about Structuring I thought I knew the difference of improvising and composing but I way off. When I thought about improvising I thought wow, musicians that improvise have to constantly think on their feet and make up something right then and there. But what this chapter showed me was the improvising isn’t completely ‘free’. Musicians don’t just create new music right there but they actually use something that already exists and builds off that. And that composing and improvising aren’t that much different just because composing is the process of creating music before-hand. Also that composing is a cognitive process that can be taking place at any time.
Nathan Parker Chapter 5 I loved how this chapter talked about improvising and composing. I like how they explained improvising, that it was "free" in a sense that it did not have to do with any preexisting lines, it was just what you thought felt and sounded good at that moment. While composing it improvising before the song it is planned out before, you even step onto the stage. This chapter also talked about how a song can totally change just by redoing the structure, it is often used today in remixes of songs. a song can start out slow and smooth and soft then be totally changed into this fast beaty hard song with just a change of a few structures.
This chapter was very interesting as far as the politics that go behind the music we listen too. The book talks about the boundaries around music like the race, sex, religion, style, and the country itself. I think that most countries like to keep some of their own music to themselves so they can be proud of what they have. The gamelan we studied is a great example of this, I have never heard anything like it until I came into this class it sounded so out of this world I couldn't wrap my mind around it. I have never heard something quite like it and I think the reason is, is because they want to keep to themselves and be proud of what they have made and accomplished with their music. I also think religion has a lot to do with it. I know some countries band all of outsiders music because they think all other music is just noise and doesn't go with their beliefs.
This chapter talks about structure in music. IT is amazing how in different cultures there are different ways to make music, and how structure is important in making music. Also that improvisation is also considered composition.
The thing that really seemed to stick out to me the most about Balinese Gamelan is the emphasis that is placed on the instruments instead of the musicians, like in our culture. Even when creating the instruments, much work goes into creating the instruments and making sure every last bit of the instrument has some kind of decoration or carving. This prevents evil from being present.
In America and other places, I receive the impression that the instrument is no more than a tool in the hands of the master, a musician. Even when watching clips of the Balinese Gamelan performances, I admire the skill of the musicians needed to play something that unique.
For Gamelan instruments, however, it's all about the instruments. The musicians are considered honored to have the opportunity to play and the instruments are even given sacred space, if you will, that should be respected. It's interesting to see what differences there are between our cultures.
Cherise Jenkins Chapter 4 This chapter was more of a review for me, but I found the idea of thinking of music in vertical and horizontal ways interesting. I had never thought of music that way and classifying what I already knew of music in those categories. Horizontal music is more of the movement in the music, the progressions. Interval progressions, scales, and modes are part of the horizontal thinking of music. Vertical music is more how the music is stacked up. Stationary intervals, chords, and harmony are among the vertical classification. Vertical and Horizontal parts of music are combined in melodies and other parts of the music. I found vertical and horizontal classifications a different point of view and I liked how well it explained the basic composition of music. Relating it to the examples of music from other cultures was also interesting and it explained the rules for vertical and horizontal music.
Cherise Jenkins Chapter 5 Structuring music really depends on the culture that you belong to. I discovered this as I read through chapter 5. There are many different ways to structure music and the purpose of the music is rather important. Depending on what the music is for, the structure of the music will be different. Sometimes it is better to put something significant first in the composition. The author of the text used the North Indian culture as an example and how they could create and structure music. A lot of music is structured for the moment. The example of the dalang in Indonesia with his puppets and musicians is used to demonstrate this. The context of the music also plays a heavy part on the structure of the music. Sacred, secular, rituals, concerts, formal, and casual all influence the style and structure of the music. The audience and place is rather important so the composers must not forget them. Social values also play a large part in music structuring. The gamelan is different from jazz, hence the different structures of music. The culture is reflected through the music and the structure of the music keeps it so. Another interesting point I learned from reading chapter 5 is the difference from composition and improvising. I had never thought of them as the exact same, but I never thought of them as completely different either. Learning the differences was informational. Composition takes place before had while improvising is made up on the spot, but is built off of the surrounding parts. Composition is often completely new. These differences are important and set the two ways of creating music apart.
42 comments:
The Balinese Gamelan
I found it to be so interesting that in this class of music that they fill that empty space is area in which corruption can happen and that evil spirits can poses it. I had wondered why they had such elaborate carvings on their instruments after seeing them on the trip to BYU. I had just imagined that the culture was very artistic and like to show off their skills with wood and art. But after all that I have learned I see that it is something very close to them as instrument makers. I really think it is amazing how religious they are and how this religion is part of the instrument itself and its creation.
I really liked that they also respected the instrument. Their feeling of reverence towards the instrument itself is very intriguing and fascinating. In our culture we give reverence to the musician that plays but with them the musician isn’t important, it is the instrument that is and they give respect to it and the amazing sound that it makes.
Jason, sent to me via e-mail:
Through this whole experience with Gamelan, listening to the different instruments,
seeing how they’re played, and getting to know the culture behind Gamelan I have come out of
this learning experience so enriched by it. I was utmost impressed with the true ensemble exists
in this type of music. But, not only the music, but the entire culture as well.
One impression I got during this experience was how I wished that our culture here in the
United States, from a cultural standpoint, could live like that! The harmony that seems to
permeate the Balinese culture because of this sense of community is astounding to me. It is so
wonderful to witness such unity. As well, despite the uneven pitches that exist in Gamelan music,
I found myself, the longer I listened to it, the more my ear got used to it and it started to have a
very peaceful effect on me. The music was calming. I could really understand why this music is
so sacred to the Balinese people.
I also found interesting was the fact that how each instrument was distinct and unique,
and that it had to be played within a certain group, compared with western music. The specialty
skill one needs to play instruments such as these is mind blowing to me. I truly admire anyone
that can play these instruments! I am so glad we took the time to discover this type of music and
this culture.
Derek Rich
The Balinese Gamelan
I thought it was interesting that they held a ceremony before the concert to ward away evil. It is remarkable to this day they hold this ceremony. The whole concert is dedicated to ward away evil and fill the empty void with music. Its cool that they decorated their instruments to convey beauty and keep evil away from harming anyone. I thought it was interesting for dancers to move in such a detail way. Also they teach this kind of dancing very young.
The way they though is kind of odd, tuning each instruments different that they almost sound good. The reason for this is that they tune them out of tune from each other. Also they have to know know the correct time to stop and or keep playing at the correct moment and let others play.
I found it weird at first how they tune their instruments, but then I noticed how great the sound came out of it, even if in my ears, they were "out of tune". Just knowing that a particular section is tuned to a certain pitch and the other sections are tuned in their own unique pitch is interesting.
Not only I found that Hindu was a major part in their culture, but I found it interesting that the Hindu religion was an important to the Balinese music as well.
I like it how not only the instruments are nicely crafted for tuning, but also the designs the instruments were given. The idea to make them sound the same AND look the same is a great idea. It gives the audience something else to look at while they hear their music being played.
It is also great that they keep the westerners away who don't know how to give proper respect to the playing area and instruments. They really like it to keep things sacred.
Balinese Gamelan-
I found Balinese Gamelan music very fascinating. I never knew instruments that were out of tune could sound so beautiful, especially when played with many other instruments in an ensemble. The shimmering sound that is produced as a result is mesmerizing. The cooperation in gamelan music is also fascinating. Their culture is perfectly reflected in their music. They strongly believe in cooperation and balance. Even when it comes to who’s rice fields can grow. In a Balinese village, the villagers figure out where the water will flood next so those people can prepare to plant their rice fields, while other people must wait to plant their rice fields until the water comes to them, so everyone can eventually get to plant their rice and have food for themselves. This cooperation is seen in their Balinese Gamelan. Each player has their own part, and if one player loses their place or forgets where they are, they will throw everyone else off. What makes it even more difficult, gamelan music is seldom performed with sheet music, and most often by memory. The performers must know the music like the back of their hand, and know other parts on other instruments as well. They all must be able to play the instruments as well as their own. All parts of Gamelan music come together as a cohesive whole. All the instruments in the Gamelan shine, and not one is just for back up music like what is common in Western music. Soloists are rare, and the instruments are the stars rather than the musicians that play them.
Anneli Fielding
Balinese Gamelan
I think it is really interesting how the people view the instruments and the music. The instruments are sacred and very special. They are to be treated with respect. It is a privilege for a person to get to display the beauty of the instrument. Gamelan players do not try to stand out or have solos. This is very different than Western music.
Religious differences between Java and Bali can be seen in their music. Javanese Gamelan tends to be quieter and more improvisational because Islam “officially disapproves of music.” I think it is amazing that none of their music is notated. I’m surprised that it has been preserved so well. The instruments themselves, are very beautifully crafted and each set of gamelan instruments are tuned to each other but will not mix with other groups of instruments. They tune their notes slightly off to create a shimmery sound.
Anneli Fielding
Ch. 4
Thinking about Pitch
I think it is very interesting how different cultures treat pitches differently. Tuning the actual instruments ais different. In Java, instruments are tuned slightly different to create a beat or shimmery sound. In western music, we try to avoid the beats. We try to match exactly the tuning note. I think it is interesting that A 440 is supposedly our standard but often orchestras will tune to 442.
Even harmonies are different in different cultures. In western music, our ears are accustom to consonant sounds. In more recent times exploration of dissonance has become more common but in other cultures dissonance in tone clusters is common.
Some cultures use microtones and quarter tones more commonly than western music. The way our modern piano is tuned has locked us into using half steps and whole steps. Music can be thought of vertically (harmonies) or horizontally (Melodies).
John Hoffman
Chapter 4
Pitch
By reading this chapter I learned what pitch actually is. I never really had to think about it until now. I understand it to be the foundation for both melody and harmony. Names are given to pitches as an aid to memory, using syllables, numbers, or letters. The syllables, which have been used in Euoropean music since 1600 are: do, re, mi fa, so, la, ti, and do. I actually learned this long ago from watching "The Sound of Music." Setting the pitch on an instrument, for example the metallophone, is done by the person who constructs the instrument, by scraping or filing away different parts of the bar.
Balinese Gamelan reading:
The distinction between orchestra and gamelan I found interesting. The fact that orchestras have specific instruments that need to be there, else it is not considered an orchestra, and gamelans do not have requirements is somewhat superising. I know that there are specifics to being in an orchestra, for example I could not play in my high school orch because I played the sax. Not an instrument that they want honking in the middle of a concerto. But then I thought about bands. There are jazz bands, marching bands, rock bands, Ryan Shupe and the “rubber band”. So there are American equivalents to the gamelans.
It is very remarkable to me that the gamelans do not have a central tuning focus. In a way it is really cool, and on the other hand it is very strange and not practical. It brings the players together and unites them, makes them loyal to that specific gamelan. But at the same time if different gamelans want to play together they can’t.
I love how everything is interconnected in gamelan music. From the instruments, to the players, the community, just the whole idea of them is togetherness.
Koteken is really neat. I like how everything interlocks with each other to make a giant whole. The idea that one player alone cannot make an entire melody ring true, and that all instruments are interdependant is a good way to bring everyone together. I like it!!
I really enjoyed learning about pitch. By reading this i was better able to see how pitch is used in melody and also in harmony. Melody is the selection of pitches in sucession. Harmony is what you hear overall or the pitches heard simultaneously. I also enjoyed learning how some intruments the pitch is fixed and on others it is set by the people. In the chapter i was also able to learn about scales and tones. Overall i really enjoyed reading this chapter. I was able to learn alot of new and interesting things and better understand music.
Chapter 4
I was so very fascinated about how different cultures tune their instruments. Notation (the language of pitch) is also very different between different cultures.
I never really thought about it before how pitch can inform an entire musical piece. But what I found really fascinating in the reading was how many different approaches there are as well to setting pitches.
Teaching pitches as well was a fascinating part of the chapter. And the idea of putting letters to different pitches made me giggle a bit. We've all grown up with Do Re Mi from "The Sound of Music." But now, as an adult, and particularly after reading this chapter, I really can see what a great way it is to teach music. It is so simply put!
Chapter 4-pitch
Pitch varies among cultures in many different ways depending how the culture interprets that pitch. Mode varies with cultures also. Modes refer to mood. The European system puts major scales as a happy mood and minor as a sad mood. Dissonance and consonance also depend on certain intervals. Microtones, 24 selections of pitches in a selection 7 pitch scale, are also used by some cultures. We need to remember that our music is not necessarily the right kind of music, and music can have the same concepts but within a different context. Some cultures don’t think of happy or sad in the context of major or minor as the European system does, but they think of fast or slow as connotating a mode. Also while the European system interprets major and minor seconds as dissonant, Bulgarian women interpret them as consonant or pleasant and smooth. Culture plays a huge role in how we hear music.
Jordan Norton
Intro to World Music
Nov. 5, 2010
Chapter 4.
Pitch is the fundamental element in both melody and harmony. Pitch is nothing more than a tone. When tones are put together they create a scale which in turn creates music. In the book Ms. Wade says “harmony can be defined as pitches heard simultaneously.” I would agree with what she says, but add that those pitches must flow together and blend for those pitches to create beautiful harmony. Such as a river flows. The tones that nature creates herself always seem to be in harmony with each other. I enjoyed learning and reading about Solfege’s. I loved seeing them put into a song and in song form. The Sound of Music illustrates this point wonderfully. It is actually my favorite song from the entire movie. I used to play the trumpet many years ago, and when I was learning we used a different form of Solfege. Instead of using letters we used numbers to indicate which valve we were to push down to play the right note and at the right pitch.
Pitches are usually set during the construction phase of instrument building. However this is not always the case. Many times a musician will alter the pitch of their instrument to suit the music that they are playing. The placement of pitch is taken from the traditions of the area in which the music is being played. A pitch setting from China will not be at the same pitch level as music from the Andes mountain region. They are made of different materials therefore they will have differing pitches.
I have found the study of pitches to be a wonderful learning opportunity that I now understand better after having matured some and can appreciate them more. It is amazing to see the different pitches from different cultures and the different way that pitch is classified. I believe that I have a better understanding for pitch and will listen better to the music that I enjoy for the harmony of those pitches. I will also listen to the harmony of pitches that are nature to see how they all connect.
Ch four
I thought this was a very interesting chapter about pitch. Pitch is how low or high a sound is. It makes up the world we live in Everything has a pitch - the sounds we hear every day like a car going down the street or the sweet sound of a muscle car reving its engine. In musical terms, “pitch is a fundamental element in both melody and harmony. Melody is a selction of pitches in succession.” It is what gives the melody that catchy feeling that you can never get out of your head. Harmony is pitches that are played at the same time. It is the underlining notes or sound that just makes everything flow.
It is interesting to see how each culture uses pitches and tones in their own way. For example, when we play a musical intrument, we want each instrument to play the same note or one that harmonizes with every other instrument in the group. Unless the purpose of the musical piece is to hurt our ears or make us grind our teeth, we want to have no conflicting noises. But in Gamelan music, they purposely tune every instrument just slightly off eachother to make a wavy, intersecting sound that we in our culture, have a hard time tolerating.
Whether it is the discordant sounds of Gamelan music, the sweet sounds of a ’67 Mustang reving its engine, or the harmonic pieces of Mozart and Rachmaninov; the differences and blending of pitches in our music make what we hear communicate the thoughts and feelings of the composer. Without it, music would cease to be what it is - amazing.
Chapter 4
Derek Rich
Chapter 4 talks about tuning in different cultures. While one country has the instrument tuned to have zero fault in it another culture would have it slightly out of tune to have a different pitch. Not only that but they actually sound good. Also how different styles of music will tune to specific pitches. It makes it pleasing to the ear.
Chapter 4 is probably my favorite chapter because it talks about how differing cultures have different pitches and that not every sound has to be the same.
Ch. 5, Thinking About Structure:
Different cultures and countries have different forms of structure for their pieces, and that is one of the things that make their music unique. The chapter discussed the multiple definitions of improvisation and composition, and I thought it interesting that for some cultures, their improvising is totally free; without some kind of rhythmic, or melodic foundation to build upon.
The chapter also talked about arrangements of songs, and how composers could rearrange a song just by changing the structure, or order of events. For example, there could a popular song that is usually slow and smooth, but a remix of the same song, is viewed totally different if it starts out with a big bang! This could either change that particular song for the better, or for the worse, depending on the audience the original, or remix was meant for.
I also liked the fact that a song style from a specific culture, will always have the same structure: the chapter gave an example of the North Indian instrumental structure in that it starts out with a main melody line at a slow tempo, then adds rhythmic flavor as the tempo speeds up.
This just proves to show us that how the music is structured and put together, is what makes it special to each particular culture.
Chapter 5- Structure
I find it fascinating how many different musical structures there are in the world. I found it very interesting how music can be performed so differently among cultures. In Middle Eastern improvised music, the musician presents a musical idea to an audience and will either prolong that idea according to the audiences reaction or will not prolong it. The audience is very interactive with the performers. If they like something they will let the performers know through gesturing or calling out any number of traditional phrases. In Balinese dalang shadow puppet performances the interaction of the master puppeteer with the musicians shapes what kind of music will be played, depending on what the puppeteer wishes to have. He will give cues to the musicians on what to play. East Arab aesthetic feedback system is much different from some European systems which are essentially sit still, and be silent until the end of the performance. Essentially Western art practices do not shape the performance as the Balinese and Arab practices may.
John Hoffman
Chapter 5 reading report
Structure
The chapter on structure was interesting in a couple of different ways. The section about improvising and composing was interesting how it highlighted the misconceptions about the two. One is that improvisation is "free" and that the music being created during a performance is not based on anything preexisting. Rather the musician may base the performance on something that already exists, like ensemble relationships, or rhythym patterns.
Structure also varies in different cultures. It is used to give the music an identity unique to the culture. The gamelan music we studied is a very good example of this.
Ch. 5 Thinking about Structuring
I really enjoyed reading chapter five. In this chapter i learned what improvising and composing are. In improvising it is important to note that music is created during the performance and is not based on anything that is already preexisting. Composing and Improvising are alot alike. Many people tend to think that composing means that nothing is being created only performed. We think that for something to be created it needs to be improvised. In the book it talked about how this is not always true because in some cultures the music isn't even written down. It also talked about how in some cultures it is important to ease into the music. To start with just a couple of instruments at a time until finally they are all playing together. It also talked about the different types of forms of playing such as the North India form, Sonata form, and others. In the chapter it talked about the importance of the music telling the story. The story that the music tells is as important as the music itself. I really enjoyed reading this chapter and was able to learn alot of new things.
Chapter 6-
I never knew how many issues there were surrounding music. Authenticity is a very interesting issue that I never really thought about. How do we figure out if something really is authentic or not? Many different types of music are more acculturated then we think. Flamenco music that we may assume originated in spain, actually has many different types of influences in the singing an dance styles in Flamenco, including Punjabi singing in India, and Jewish synagogue chants. The poverty of a country shapes what their music is like; lack of resources, poor living conditions, and little income all affect their music. If the people don’t have a lot of money to buy well crafted instruments, they will have to use the available resources around them, whatever they are. The Central Africa Republic is an example of this. The only instruments they can afford is handmade instruments made from what little resources there are around them. They are also a people who always must focus on survival, and this affects their music as well. They don’t have a lot of movement in their dancing and they have simple music, so they can save their energy for survival.
Ch. 6
I now have a better understanding of all the issues that surround music. The problem that it states in the book is that nothing is truly global, consumed, produced or understood in the same way. Everyone has different opinions and this creates many issues in music. It talks about the issue about what is world music? Really many things could be considered world music. Should it just be the music that is foreign or are the musicians that play rock just mainstream? In the chapter it also talked about the different types of identities. There are many different types of identities throughout the world. Music is the same ways. There are a lot of different identities and it is hard to identify each one. Another issue is authenticity. Who came up with the music and who does it belong to? I really enjoyed reading this chapter and was able to learn a lot. I didn't realize all the issues in music and now I have a better understanding.
These are probably too late to turn in, but I'm doing it anyways...
Ch 4-Thinking about Pitch
I never saw Harmony and Melody before how they explained, as in Melody being a horizontal figure of pitch and Harmony being a vertical figure of pitch. Instruments that have a fixed pitch are usually manufactured into this standard, but the instrumentalists without the fixed pitch have the job to adjust its pitch. The notes are usually apart by whole steps or half steps as they are called intervals. The spaces between notes also get higher as the interval changes as in C to D is a whole step (major 2nd) and C to F is 2 wholes and a half (major 4th). There are also intervals smaller than the half step. Some of them are called microtones and others are called quartertones. None of these fit in the Western scales in music, but usually featured in Arab music, which is based on a theory of having pitches in an octave.
CH 5-Thinking About Structuring
There are 2 kinds of structures in music. One of them is to improvise and the other one is composition. The improvising part is being completely free in doing anything that isn't based in anything preexisting. The composition is based on a given music. It can also be called improvising, but it's not completely free because of the given music prior to that, as it is called composition for that matter. Usually, a composition is replayable, unlike improvising, it's basically a solo that would most likely not be played again, unless if intended to.
In some places, like in Indonesia, there are people called dalang, which is a puppeteer. He sings cues to the musicians and play songs that are appropriate to the scene. The musicians have a written piece of music to play, but they don't know when to play it. I thought that idea was pretty cool.
Chapter 5
This chapter was very interesting. I had never thought before that improvisation could be considered composition before. But it makes sense. In improvisation, composition takes place during a performance, regular composing takes place before a performance. This brings me back to the many jazz concerts I have enjoyed and now after reading this chapter I now have a deeper understanding and appreciation for what they do.
The contrasting ways that different countries as well, structure their music I also found fascinating. Also I appreciated the time the author took in this chapter on Context and why composers structure their compositions the way they do. Particularly I was fascinated by vocal pieces. I had never really thought about how composers put certain lyrics on high notes and others on low ones, and how they compose the music to emphasize certain lyrics. Basically, this all has to do with context. This chapter really opened up my eyes to the endless possibilities of structure and how it can be manipulated, as well as how culture can play a significant role in the structure of music of that specific culture.
Chapter 6
The things I want to focus on in this report, that really stood out for me in this chapter are the issues of political, authenticity and culture.
I had never really thought about how the politics of a nation could be an issue with the music of that specific nation. I am amazed throughout history how music sometimes has been underground in oppressive regimes like in Afghanistan under the rule of the Taliban. Even the folk music specific to a nation can be influenced politically. How communism in China has influenced the music greatly because of its rigid practices and its strict governance over anything that can be construed as subversive.
Culture I already was aware as an issue in music but as I am preparing for my part in the final project I’m doing on Navajo music I am fascinated by how music is so deeply rooted in this culture. Traditions are passed down from generation to generation and how it is treated as sacred! You can see culturally how bluegrass music was influenced. The simplicity of the people really translates into that particular style of music.
Finally, the issue of authenticity; I can really see now how this can become an issue with music. Particularly with oral traditions passed down, it is important that a certain amount of authenticity be maintained, and how easily it might not be maintained as it passes down through the generations. Copyright issues play a big factor in this as well. This chapter reminded me recently of an issue with the new Michael Jackson CD coming out early next year, and how a certain song that was supposed to be hidden one, experts are now saying doesn’t sound like him. I listened to it on the radio and I agree. So authenticity is a really big issue.
This chapter I enjoyed the most. It really covered so many things I had never really thought much about.
Chapter 6: Thinking About Issues
As we discussed in class, there are many issues and ways that cultures, and music can be either lost, or refined around the world. The book gives several examples, such as boundries, religions, gender, and believe it or not, I think a lot has to do with what type/style of music surrounding countries are listening to. The author gives the example of when she traveled to Tahiti (French Polynesia) the youth there wanted to listen to the typical American music; rock and roll, hip-hop, etc. The music of Tahiti still stays on pretty prevalent, but it is being forced to accommodate western music as well.
I think that this could provide good issues, and bad. It is good, in the fact that the youth and people around the world are expanding their horizons when it comes to a variety of music. It is bad, in that cultures are morphing, and a lot of them are taking their ancient music, and modernizing them to make them more attractive to the ears of people today. Okay, this is not necessarily a bad thing, but it does make one wonder; how many cultures have changed because of the influence of surrounding countries? How many ancient styles of music were lost because the music played has to match what the people want to listen to today?
Chapter 4
I found it interesting how so many different cultures look at pitch completly different. They each have their own take on what is pleasing, and what is not. I find it amazing how many different systems there are for assigning pitch.
In western music we seem to leave out a lot of things that could make our music more interesting. I think that is why I like electronic music so much, it opens pitches that you would not normally have in westen music.
The bali instruments still facinate me, how they are tuned in pairs and work in unison with each other to produce slight waves in the pitch that you hear.
The quality of instruments avalible seem to have a fair bit to do with the pitches that are avalible for a culture, thus influencing the scales, and music itself, how it is put together.
It makes perfect sense to me because I read music, but the way they describe harmony in the book is very visual, the horizontal and vertical idea. LIke I said it makes perfect sense I just don't think I have thought of it that way before.
The whole cd the you tube clip was linked to is really good about Ashley Macisaac. The Irish group might find it interesting to listen to, especially the fiddle player, sorry I forgot your name, Anali maybe. Sorry.
Chapter 5
The battle between composing and inprovisation is an interesting one. I can understand how ethnomusicologists think that some imporvisation is composing, and how composing is really just a vastly slowed down process of improv.
I agree with both ideas. I think I agree more that improv can be a form of composition because to be able to do imporv you have to know the rules, scales, and information that you would need to know to compose a piece.
I find that strophic compositions are easier to do than are through compositions. They also add to being able to recall the song better and eaiser.
Rondo form adds a little bit to the rememberablity (new word of the day) of a song. If you can repeat the same kind of thing over and over it lends to a sense of unity to the piece.
The written music can seem to loose a little of it's appeal after awhile because it is played the same way over and over. however for evaluation purposes, and playablity purposes this lends itself nicly. It also makes it so everyone can play it not just those that are educated in the way of music.
If you like rock music it gives a nice exapmle to how you can blend improv and composition. Bands come up with the songs that they record and sell, but if you go to a concert you see them improv almost all the time. It makes it exciting to go to concerts because you know you are going to hear somthing new.
Chapter 6
As an American I am very national, very proud and happy to be an American. I think that many other nations are the same way. They have their style of music and that is what they think about, they could care less about others around them. After all the world music is just noise anyway. This kind of thinking is sad because one of the neatest things in the world is hearing a song you know well, but hearing it in a new way. A pop song played on the bagpipes with a little bit of an Irish twist on it is neat.
The issue of gender is a hard one to wrap my brain around now a days. It seems that it would not be an issue anymore, but it obviously is. In a lot of nations women are forbidden to perform types of music. This is sad because of the different textures, touches and emotions women can breath into music. Having that social status is an issue too.
The religious aspects of music hit home to me a lot. I am a very religious person, and as such I miss out of some of the different musics of the world. If it does not sit well with my beliefs and values I tend to ignore that kind of music. I try and still keep an open mind and not shun generes, but rather song. I know that this is not so with others. Look historically at how great a role churches have played in music. In western music it is huge, in all nations it has roots there. If the music does not meet up to a certain standard of morality, or values in many cultures it is shuned or obliterated, or stopped from progressing. An example there is a fiddle player from Scotland who as the story goes actually got kicked out of the contry for (desecrating) traditional Scotish songs, of course that is just the story I have heard, so don't quote me on it:^). You should look him up his name is Ashley Macisaac, and he is increadible. Here is a link for ya if you choose to look him up. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HGe9PLC8SL0
Just FYI: Ashley MacIsaac is Canadian, from Cape Breton Island, which is an enclave of celtic music. Super-good musicians seem to grow up on that island!
Chase Rollins
Chapter Reports
Chapter #4 Thinking about Pitch
Pitch is a element that is in both melody and harmony that makes it fundamental. Pitch can be in simple terms as tones, and get more complex to the formation of intervals and scales. Pitch although known to be an element for melody(which is thinking horizontally) and for harmony(which is thinking vertical) which means that all notes in music are from left to right and start from the top of a page and go to the bottom. Pitch to some people is the different between the highness and lowness of music. This shows how all music has high pitched sounds that can hurt our ears, example is like the screeching of tires. And can also be a very low pitch that is easy on us which is like a roar from a motorcycle engine. Without the difference in pitches in a song or piece of music, we would get bored with the repetition of a song. This would create no great music to us and all would seem the same. Pitch is a must to all music around the world. If we use music without pitch like I said it would be boring and no one would care to create new music or listen because all is the same.
James Fairbank
Chapter report 5
In the thinking musically book, in the chapter thinking about structure the thing that stood out to me was the improvising and composing. This stood out to me because I hold improvisation very close to me. I loved to improvise all the time. Improvisation is defined in the book as,” the process of interweaving musical material that is given with material that is newly created even as one listens. This is closely associated with composing. One example of this is typically in the song April in Paris by the Count Basie orchestra they have a solo that was improvised when making it by Thad Jones. That solo was so popular to the song that the improvisation was composed into what the song is today. This is a prime example of how improvisation can be tied into composing. I also learned in this chapter that when a person is improvising its sort of their way of telling a story to the audience. For example when one improvises the way you flow with the music would be to that of how a story is told. A story could be the three pigs. When the pigs are scared you accent more on the notes and when they are all safe in the brick house you would use some slurs to represent that. When the big bad wolf tries to blow the house down you could throw in some crescendos and decrescendos. That is how I would describe telling a story with the improvisation.
The Balinese Gamelan Reading
The balinese Gamelan is awesome! I absolutly love there style and they way there music sounds. I this is crazy how much time they put into their insruments, what was it like 3 mounths to tune there instruments. The way they tune them is cool to, they tune the other insruments a half a note off from the other so that you get that crazy sound out of them. The design of the instruments is amazing to. it must take them forever to do it. I also thought it was cool that each of the carvings accually have a story to them. They are truly amazing down in bali. It is also amazing how many instruments are in the gamelan. there are tones. This was defenetly one of my favorite things I have learnd this year.
chapter 4
I really thought it to be interesting that as you travel form one culture to another you find that the idea a correct pitch changes. In western music we want all of the instrument to be tuned exactly the same thus giving It what we claim to be harmony but if you look at bale music they have every instrument tuned just off of each other so that you can hear the conflicting waves of sound that give it a wobbly sound. I found it to be very funny that we always try to tune to A or to 440 but that we as human can’t have a perfect pitch but that even the best of the western musicians will tune to 442 over 440.
Another interesting difference that is found throughout the world is how we tune a note. We in western music have a set scale of notes no more no less and if you play out of this note you are considered out of tune. This is not so in other coulters of the world where they have usable note in-between out have and quarter notes giving them a larger rage of usable tones and give them to us a out of tune sound
Chapter 5
Scott Christian
I think that the structure of music is something very individual to every culture. There are so many different ways to compose music. We being raised in the western music form find it to be the clearest and simplest to understand. With it we are able to write music from all over the world in a way that it can be played and understand by us. But if we look at the forms of composition from say Japan we don’t find exactly notes but more of how to play the song. It tends to be longer and more detailed in how you should play it but in western music not so much so. But that is something I love! We have the great opportunity to put out personality into the music that we play. We can play the music exactly how it is written but that is just playing notes to me, it is in the moment that we take the music can make it part of us and actually feel it in us it that we are truly able to make it alive and free. This isn’t as possible in other cultures music because they are tolled exactly what to do.
Posting for Ashley:
Ch. 4 Thinking about pitch
I thought it was really cool to learn about how other cultures tuned their instruments. Some would tune theirs to sound slightly off in order to create a shimmery sound when played. And at first when I heard it, the sound bothered me because I wasn’t used to it and it sounded off to me. But when I learned about them more I was able to really listen for the shimmer affect that they were going for.
Before reading this chapter I never knew about a lot of the terms that were talked about. For example terms like chord progression, heterophony or diatonic scales. But know I know that chord progression is a sequence of chords. A heterophony is when multiple musicians perform one melody, but each musician might render the melody differently. And that diatonic scales are arrangements of half steps and whole steps.
Also when reading about teaching pitches, thought back to the Sound of Music movie and realized back when I would watch it has a child that I was actually being taught pitches without even knowing it. It cool how a simple song like that forever sticks with you as you grow up, and not realizing that you something about music even if you never spent a day in your life in class being taught it.
Ch. 5 Thinking about Structuring
I thought I knew the difference of improvising and composing but I way off. When I thought about improvising I thought wow, musicians that improvise have to constantly think on their feet and make up something right then and there. But what this chapter showed me was the improvising isn’t completely ‘free’. Musicians don’t just create new music right there but they actually use something that already exists and builds off that. And that composing and improvising aren’t that much different just because composing is the process of creating music before-hand. Also that composing is a cognitive process that can be taking place at any time.
Nathan Parker
Chapter 5
I loved how this chapter talked about improvising and composing. I like how they explained improvising, that it was "free" in a sense that it did not have to do with any preexisting lines, it was just what you thought felt and sounded good at that moment. While composing it improvising before the song it is planned out before, you even step onto the stage. This chapter also talked about how a song can totally change just by redoing the structure, it is often used today in remixes of songs. a song can start out slow and smooth and soft then be totally changed into this fast beaty hard song with just a change of a few structures.
Nathan Parker
Chapter 6
This chapter was very interesting as far as the politics that go behind the music we listen too. The book talks about the boundaries around music like the race, sex, religion, style, and the country itself. I think that most countries like to keep some of their own music to themselves so they can be proud of what they have. The gamelan we studied is a great example of this, I have never heard anything like it until I came into this class it sounded so out of this world I couldn't wrap my mind around it. I have never heard something quite like it and I think the reason is, is because they want to keep to themselves and be proud of what they have made and accomplished with their music.
I also think religion has a lot to do with it. I know some countries band all of outsiders music because they think all other music is just noise and doesn't go with their beliefs.
Derek Rich
Chapter 5
This chapter talks about structure in music. IT is amazing how in different cultures there are different ways to make music, and how structure is important in making music. Also that improvisation is also considered composition.
Balinese Gamelan Reading Report
The thing that really seemed to stick out to me the most about Balinese Gamelan is the emphasis that is placed on the instruments instead of the musicians, like in our culture. Even when creating the instruments, much work goes into creating the instruments and making sure every last bit of the instrument has some kind of decoration or carving. This prevents evil from being present.
In America and other places, I receive the impression that the instrument is no more than a tool in the hands of the master, a musician. Even when watching clips of the Balinese Gamelan performances, I admire the skill of the musicians needed to play something that unique.
For Gamelan instruments, however, it's all about the instruments. The musicians are considered honored to have the opportunity to play and the instruments are even given sacred space, if you will, that should be respected. It's interesting to see what differences there are between our cultures.
Cherise Jenkins
Chapter 4
This chapter was more of a review for me, but I found the idea of thinking of music in vertical and horizontal ways interesting. I had never thought of music that way and classifying what I already knew of music in those categories. Horizontal music is more of the movement in the music, the progressions. Interval progressions, scales, and modes are part of the horizontal thinking of music. Vertical music is more how the music is stacked up. Stationary intervals, chords, and harmony are among the vertical classification. Vertical and Horizontal parts of music are combined in melodies and other parts of the music. I found vertical and horizontal classifications a different point of view and I liked how well it explained the basic composition of music. Relating it to the examples of music from other cultures was also interesting and it explained the rules for vertical and horizontal music.
Cherise Jenkins
Chapter 5
Structuring music really depends on the culture that you belong to. I discovered this as I read through chapter 5. There are many different ways to structure music and the purpose of the music is rather important. Depending on what the music is for, the structure of the music will be different. Sometimes it is better to put something significant first in the composition. The author of the text used the North Indian culture as an example and how they could create and structure music. A lot of music is structured for the moment. The example of the dalang in Indonesia with his puppets and musicians is used to demonstrate this. The context of the music also plays a heavy part on the structure of the music. Sacred, secular, rituals, concerts, formal, and casual all influence the style and structure of the music. The audience and place is rather important so the composers must not forget them. Social values also play a large part in music structuring. The gamelan is different from jazz, hence the different structures of music. The culture is reflected through the music and the structure of the music keeps it so. Another interesting point I learned from reading chapter 5 is the difference from composition and improvising. I had never thought of them as the exact same, but I never thought of them as completely different either. Learning the differences was informational. Composition takes place before had while improvising is made up on the spot, but is built off of the surrounding parts. Composition is often completely new. These differences are important and set the two ways of creating music apart.
Post a Comment