Bollywood Film Music / Bollywood Readings

Here is a place to post your response to the Bollywood film you watch -- and especially your response to its music! I hope you will love this music like I do!

This is also the place to post your responses to what you have read about Bollywood film music. Here is another link to the readings:
Kabir, Nasreen Muni 
Jaikumar, Priya
To access these readings, you will need a google docs invitation. Please comment here or email me if you don't have access and need/want it.

To give you an idea about the length and substance required for papers or posts, a sample follows in the comments section.

26 comments:

Myrna said...

Sample comment worth full points:

Bollywood Movie Review: Kuch Naa Kaho

I really enjoyed this movie and think it is worth watching! It was so different from what I expected and what I am used to, yet it was really good. The title of the movie translates as “Don’t say anything.” This is a very appropriate title because the female lead is often in situations where she needs to explain herself or tell someone something, but people are cutting her off and sometimes even putting a finger over her lips to silence her.
Thank goodness that, in Bollywood films, she has the opportunity to at least sing! And the songs are wonderful. The first song “Baat meri suniye to zara” pits the female and male leads (Namrata and Raj) against each other, since she has discovered that the man she met at the airport – Raj—lied to her and she feels the need to tell him off. This song also has amazing dance moves, to make it that much more fun to watch and listen to.
But my favorite song has to be “ABBG.” This song takes place at the school that Adi, Namrata’s son, attends. The song is a hilarious mix of Panjabi, Hindi and English—although not so hilarious, I suppose, if you don’t have some understanding of these languages and the puns that result from being bilingual. In the song, children hold up cards with letters of the English alphabet, but the words that the letters represent may be in any of the three languages. For example “TPOG” are the letters on the cards in one sequence but in this case the T stands for the English tea, which the characters are drinking and PO stand for “piyo” a form of the verb “to drink” in Hindi, and G stands for the Hindi honorific “ji” (the equivalent of sir or madame) so it is basically asking “would you like to drink some tea, sir?” And several of the letter sequences use “PR” which stands for “pyar” one of the words that means love—and the children appropriately tease about love as children universally sometimes do! Very cute song!

Anneli & Jordan said...

Bollywood Music Review: Devdas
By: Anneli Fielding

I really enjoyed this movie. This is the first Bollywood movie I have seen. I would like to see more. The only downside is that you had to read the subtitles and that took my eyes off the action some. Devdas was really tragic. It made me cry a lot. Devdas and Paro were childhood friends and sweethearts. Devdas leaves for London to become a lawyer. After ten years, he returns and reunites with his family and Paro. Devdas and Paro are deeply in love but Devdas family won’t allow their marriage because Paro’s family is not of a high enough class. Ironically Paro marries into a very wealthy and high class, while Devdas shames his family by running off and constantly drinking alcohol in a whorehouse. Devdas drinks so much that it becomes poison to his body and he dies. He has promised Paro before he died he would come to her doorstep. The last scene is incredibly sad as Devdas is lying outside the gate and Paro is trying to get to him but her husband is trying to stop her and shuts the gate right before she gets out.
I especially liked the music and the dancing. I think that is what keeps it enjoyable because it is a very long movie and is slow moving. The music and dancing helps create relationships between the characters. I love the excitement in the music; it is so lively and fun. Their voices take a while to get used to. They sing in a nasally style that I wouldn’t have considered desirable. The dancing was beautiful. They used their hands in cool ways that I’m sure meant something in their culture. They use bells around their ankles to create a rhythm sound that goes with their dancing. The choreographing was very good and the dancers were all together. Their costumes really added to the beauty of the dance. The women were all so beautiful.
I love learning about other cultures especially their music and dance. This was really fun to watch a Bollywood film.

The bor said...

Bollywood Spectacular reading response:
The beginning of this story reminds me of the Wal-mart controversy, the big Hollywood making it hard for the rest of the world to keep their own film industry going, or get it off the ground at all. It also sounds that the term “Bollywood” is offensive to Indians, which I have never really realized how it could be like a slap in the face.
I found the idea of “Masala” interesting. The way the author described all the differing ingredients that go into making a Bollywood film is quite interesting. It seems like the flavors would conflict. She does make the point to say in a way that the taste for outsiders would be a little un-palateable, or as she says the “make little sense”. She makes it sound like the differences between genres are very subtle, because all Bollywood films have the same kind of base.
Bollywood has had bouts of “westernization” however they always seem to come back to their sense of "Indianness”. In that way I kind of admire them. Even in their move outside of mainstream movies they tend to keep the same values.
It sounds like if you want to get things past the censorship boards in India all you have to do is put whatever it is you are trying to say into a song and almost anything is okay. It also sounds that songs play as important of a role as does the film itself.
More and more movies in the U.S. are starting to showcase Bollywood style movies, and some are incorporating that kind of style. I really like that Indian filmmaking just keeps on rolling along by itself, and that the people still like fanciful movies. I miss that in our movies now days. I don’t like going to movies and having the main character die in the end just because. Or have the story be so real that I leave the theater more depressed about life than when I entered it. I miss movies transporting me to some other place, into someone else’s story where good wins, and the loser gets the girl in the end because he is a good guy.

Scott said...

Bollywood movie: Lagaan
By: Scott Christian

I really liked this movie a lot. There was so much emotion in every act that you watched. This movie tells the story of a young village man named Bhuvan that does what his heart feels is right even thought it turns the village agents him. I really loved the music especial how it was used to show the change in the people. At the beginning no one is with Bhuvan and they won’t dance with him but as each some progresses more people join them till almost everyone is on his side.
I really like the character development in this movie. If we are given the chance to live outside of our, to say normal couture we have two options. The first is to hate it and to try and change the people to be more like us like Captain Andrew Russell tried to do. We feel that only our way is right and we do all that we can to try and change others. The second way would to be more like Elizabeth. We have to fall in love with the people there culture and in the end their music. In this I feel it teach that if we give the music a chance or the culture we can in the end learn to enjoy it. I feel a little bit like Elizabeth Russell did towards the people. I really like then India music but I have stronger feelings towards Latin music. This I feel is all basted on how much time we allow ourselves to be submersed in the music of that culture.
Over all I really liked Lagaan but it was way long and my eyes did hurt after having to read the subtitles for 4 hours but overall it was great and has a great story to tell.

Aileen Keliiliki said...

Kuch Naa Kaho
In my opinion, the best and most intriguing love stories are those where the lovers have to go through hate, dislike, or trials, before they realize their love for each other. This includes classics like Pride and Prejudice, Sandra Bullock’s The Proposal, Beauty and The Beast, Singing in The Rain etc. This movie from Bollywood’s cinema was no different. Main characters, Raj and Namrata, hit it off from the very beginning when Raj tells her a detailed story about a dying son he doesn’t have, in order to secure a seat on the flight headed to Mumbai from the United States. Amidst several lies and buckets of trouble, Raj finds himself attending his cousin’s engagement ceremony, only to find himself face to face with Namrata, the girl he had lied to, who happens to be his cousin’s best friend and wedding dress designer. Namrata ends up being hired as Raj’s chaperone as his Uncle tries to set him up to meet several eligible young ladies he could marry. In the end, it is Namrata he chooses.
The music in the piece, signified the true feelings of the characters and gave a sense of time, day dreaming, and realization. The very first musical scene that started out the movie was after Namrata had figured out Raj’s deceit at his cousin’s engagement ceremony. It turns into a debate between the men and the women at the ceremony. The men claim that the women are naïve, and that females are only beautiful, because the men say they are and compare their “lips to buds” and “dark hair to the night”. It basically comes down to it that women cannot live without the affection, charms, and smarts of the men. The women try to argue that the men are easily affected by their charms because of themselves, and that the men aren’t as intelligent as they deem themselves to be. Back and forth it goes, the men incorporating movements that are more masculine and square with constant shrugging of the shoulders. This gave the men a relaxed, carefree sort of look. Their tenor voices were clear with few rolls and decorative trills. The women however, had constant looks of either anxiety, or slight seduction as they danced. Their movements were more large and airy, yet fluid and graceful. Their voices were very high and bright, and incorporated more trills and quick ‘runs’ than the men did. I also noticed that there were small bells that played during the female verses, giving the women a background image of shimmering, and glistening lightness. This first piece of music was a perfect example in showing the differences between the men’s dancing, and the women’s. The costumes helped accentuate the difference; the men wore more simple clothing, with hardly anything on their heads, where the females were dressed in many colors, some bright, and some more on the pastel side, but still flowing and sheer to match their movements with many diamonds and shining head pieces. The main purpose of the scene, was to show the tense atmosphere between Raj and Namrata and their immediate dislike and argumentative reaction towards one another.

Kristy said...

Sept. 15, 2010
Kristy Tymon
8:00-8:50am class
Intro to World Music

I have appreciated being exposed to the differences of “Hollywood & “Bollywood
styles of film making. I grew up in an era where films and T.V. were concerned about teaching very important moral values to their families. Where the films and shows modeled behavior that we wanted our children to emulate. Film makers and TV programmers took the responsibility of helping parents reinforce basic principles of truth, love, and respect for ones family and oneself. Many former film-makers realized that if they could have a positive impact on the family then they would be conrtibuting to society as a whole.
Hollywood has regressed from portraying that which is good to emphasizing baser and fouler behavior as being the condoned norm. Immoral behavior gets the prize and chaste behavior gets mocked. I think the reason I have enjoyed this section on India and “ Bollywood” is because I feel they haven’t sold out to “the popular ways of the western world”. The film’s, characters and music, reawakens the beauty of relationships felt by the heart. With so many broken relationships in our world today, their portrayal of love with childlike innocence is so refreshing. I didn’t have to worry about being exposed to anything bad. I could truly just relax, sit back and enjoy the show. I love that ALL their musicals are family friendly. Family is central to their Indian Culture. To our western culture their films, might be thought of as a little corny and sappy, but for me I am very proud of their decision to not sell out to the almighty buck when it comes to making their films. It is true that a lot of the story lines are predictable. That they are about boy meets girl– they develop a story line of them not being able to be together in the beginning of the film, but in the end “they live happily ever after- deeply in love and devoted to one another. (Is that so bad).
Their music is happy and lively. It makes you want to sing and dance with them. Their costumes use vibrant and beautiful colors. Their costumes are more modest than Hollywood for sure.
When I watch movies or TV- it is because I want a way to escape the stresses and frustrations of life. I want to be transported to a happier place and when I have finished watching and listening to the music, I want to feel refreshed and ready to face another day.
I like the sound of the sitar and I am amazed at the instrument not having recognizable fret work. I am also impressed at their aural skills and accuracy as they play their instruments. I look forward to watching and listening to more Indian music and films. I am going to try to mimic the singing I hear in the films. It is more nasal, sung more from the chest than what I do, and has a different tonal quality about it, but it should be fun to try.

Nick rowley said...

Bollywood Movie Review: Lagaan

I really enjoyed this movie. It had a very good story to it. I really enjoyed it because it was very inspiring. The movie is about a young man by the name of Bhuvan. He lives in a village called Champaner which was under British containment. It is a story about courage and doing what is right. At first everyone is not willing to listen and to trust in Bhuvan but over time he gains their trust and gets people to follow him. A young girl by the name of Elizabeth who was from England and went to India falls in love with their culture and their way of life. She gets Bhuvan to believe in himself and to stand up for what he knows is right. The British(mainly Captain Russel) wants to change the people and wants them to believe that the way he does things is the right way. But in the end because the Bhuvan and his people believe in their selves they are the victors. The music in this movie was very different from what I was used to. I really enjoyed it at first but I am not going to lie, because the movie was so long and I wasn’t used to listening to that kind of music I ended up with a big headache. The music shows a lot of emotion and this is what I enjoyed. I believe if I listened to it before or more often I would be able to enjoy it a lot more. The movie was about four hours long and reading subtitles and listening to the music that is a different type of music was like ringing to my ears. The one thing that I really enjoyed about the film was that when the music was playing I could feel the emotion. I believe that the music is something that you have to get used to by listening often. If you did that or understood the language than you would be able to feel even more emotion. I really enjoyed the plot to this movie and think that if it was just two hours long instead of four I would have enjoyed it even more. Overall Lagaan was a good movie and definitely opened my eyes to a different style of music.

Jordan said...

The Bollywood film music we have been studying in class and reading about on our own has been very interesting to learn of. All of the dubbing and voice over’s that take place to make a film are incredible all in themselves. A singer needs to convey the feelings that the director has in mind for the film. Although these singers are not dancing around like the actors they are covering for, they need to give the emotional feeling that they are dancing around or falling in love or giving courage to themselves and others. We could go on with the feelings that they are trying to give to the audience.
Songs in Bollywood films have their roots in the very first film with music and sound back in 1931 Alma Ara. Since that time music has been a key part of the Indian film industry. Unlike the American film industry which has strayed from having their actors and actresses sing in films such as “singing in the rain”, “Seven brides for seven brothers” (my personal favorite). These films had a higher moral standard than films do know. The main thing a Bollywood film has is a very high moral standard; this is because they want all people to enjoy the film. Indian culture is still highly dictated by the family and family values. This concept is very appealing to many in the Asian area of the world and to those people who are from this area or whose ancestors came from this part of the world. Because of this value system these films attract more people than American films do. Maybe not so much in the way of profit but in the number of shear people who view them.
The Bollywood film audience understands and accepts repetition in the films they see. How many times can a story or storyline be remade or retold. We in the American audience despise repetition in our films and will shun and criticize these films to no end. The only way that this will happen in Bollywood is if the film does not have any original music to it. The music is the key to all Bollywood films. The reason this so is that music is in every aspect of Indian life. There can be singing and dancing at a funeral. Yet our cultures and not that far apart, even though we like to think that they are. We in America love our music just as much as the Indian people do. We may not go around singing songs from movie soundtracks but we do sing songs by our favorite artists all the time.
Music plays a very big part in film, it is a medium by which a store is told. It is a way to paint a picture with words when you want people to use their imaginations to fill in the blanks or a way for people to transport themselves into the story, a way for them to live out their fantasies, for them to be the hero or heroine. Adding song and dance to a film is a way to make up for a poor story line which most of the early films had. The dance sequences when filmed with the songs and signing helped to further the plot and to help progress the characters. How many times have we seen in film a character who was made out to be a weakling or someone that you normally would not take notice to? How many times has that character been transformed through the help of song into a courageous character? Music is the essence to any film; this is especially true for all Bollywood films.
In conclusion the Bollywood film community has got something with making their films for all ages to enjoy. Something that all people can relate to is music and dance. Good job Bollywood you have done something that most people have a hard time doing with each other and that is relating.

Jordan Norton

Anneli & Jordan said...

Anneli Fielding
Bollywood Readings

The most notable difference from Hollywood movies is that Bollywood features lots of singing and dancing. These scenes tend to make the movie a lot longer. Music and dance transcend language barriers. Even if a person doesn’t speak the language of the movie, they can enjoy the beauties of song and dance. Hollywood movies tend to be based on realism whereas Bollywood movies have lots of fantacy.
Hollywood movies are very successful and are sold all over the world. Despite this, Bollywood movies remain loved and dear to people of India and many other foreign countries.
Indians have very conservative ideals of sexual behavior and social relations. As more people are being exposed to western way of life, Bollywood has maintained its conservative ideals while keeping up with modern trends.
Masala literally means a blend of spices that adds flavor to food. Bollywood films are often called Masala films because of the combination of many film ideas or “ingredients” that will appeal to all types of audiences. Bollywood movies don’t have genres like Hollywood does. Indian films contain romance, action, comedy, drama and tragedy. All parts of Hindi films work together to create a masterwork.
The Music is so important because a film gets lots of funding from presales of the soundtracks. If people love the music they will go to see the movie. This is why there is so much effort into creating great musical numbers.
I think that it is so great that Bollywood is gaining international recognition and respect.

Scott said...

Scott Christian

Ballywood Reading

I found it to be very interesting that in Ballywood and other groups that make movies in India that they have a fear of putting too much money into a movie for fear of not making sufficient to pay for its castes. For this there are a lot of low budget films in India. This I feel is different from us because in the US we have the ability to sell tickets for a higher price and have better advertisements for our movies. I also thought it to be interesting what was said that in Ballywood there is no such thing as a action movie or a musical because all of there movies have that in them. That if they didn’t have dancing and music they wouldn’t be Ballywood. I like how it talked a little about how they try to add a little bit of western movie in to there movies but that they always focus their movies to be family based and that they try to help teach and uplift.
I think it to be very interesting also that they tend to do advertising with the music and dances in the movie. They will show these to the public and that is what will really bring in the people because they come to hear a certain singer and because the choreograph in the dance is put together really well.
Something I found to be unique and interesting is that in almost all of their movies they said that there is always two lovers that are falling more in love and that there will always be a song and dace of when they finely can come together or their lives have been change in a way that they can never be with each other again. There movie always has this to be a epic and central part to the story line and the progression of the film.
And one more thing that I found to be very interesting was that it wasn’t till just recently that the Indian government allowed out side companies to sponsor movies and to help pay for them.

Professor McKinney said...

Bollywood Readings

Kabir:I found the parallels between Bollywood and Hollywood to be fascinated. In Bollywood, apparently, for a film to be successful it simply needs some really great song and dance numbers; while in Hollywood, we often find that films can "get by" with an underdeveloped plot, poor writing style, bad musical selection, etc. as long as it is supported with an all-star cast. While in India it would seem that most movie-goers are interested in the music, in the West would seem that most movie-goers are interested in the actors and actresses who play the roles.
What I found extremely interesting was the descriptions of the status of Bollywood films to the population of India. When talking about "Balaam ayo baso meri man main" and how the memory is ingrained in most of the Indians' memories, I began to think of similar Hollywood moments that most Westerners would be able to remember as a body. Perhaps the "I see dead people" moment in The Sixth Sense or the "Here's looking at you kid" line from Casablanca. As an English speaking American audience finds certain lines memorable, so it would seem that the Indian multilingual community attaches itself to memorable song sequences.
Also, reading about the music composed for films during the Golden Age of Indian Cinema reminded me a great deal of the early composers such as Korngold-- classically trained Jewish composers in the Viennese School who fled during World War II and took up residency in Hollywood writing film scores to pay the bills. The only Cello Concerto written by Korngold was originally for a film involving a character who was a cellist. Many of the greats still exist in Hollywood such as John Williams, and the music of Philip Glass was the keystone in "The Hours."


Jaikumar: I think the most interesting aspect of the article was simply the realization that Bollywood has to work with an Indian population that has no real central culture. Even language can be a barrier to people living within the same country. While the United States has Hollywood with small independent satellites, India has three major film industry capitals. I also loved the aspects of resisting Westernization--while even wearing Western styles the characters still are "Indian" (and the inappropriate behavior is curtailed by fate).

Professor McKinney said...

Bollywood Film Music: Umroa Jaan

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q0rK7b-yJ1o

The film is a remake of a 1981 film by the same name, both being based on the novel by Mirza Hadi Ruswa. It is not like mainstream Bollywood films--the only dancing in the film being formal with Umroa almost always being the main the attraction. She is also the main singer in the film with the only other singing being done by Nawab Sultan, which happens only once and half-way through the film. The writing of the film has obviously been influenced by poetry, a lot of the lines being hard to accept simply because of the color of the language.

The film is based on the extremely tragic and arguably true life of Umroa Jaan, a famous courtesan in Lucknow. Umroa Jaan is kidnapped from her family by an enemy of her father's--a very tragic scene as her father tries to convince the man that they are not enemies as Umroa looks through the cracks in the burlap sack in which her kidnapper has imprisoned her. She is raised in a brothel (a very G rated one I might add) and becomes one of the leading cortesans. She falls in love with Nawab Sultan, a rich customer, only to have her lover stab a man who makes advances towards her and subsequently be forced to flee. Eventually fate completely destroys Umroa in extremely unexpected ways, leaving her to sing her unhappy tale to any who will hear. One of the artistic devices I found interesting was how the turn of fate for Umroa occurs almost precisely halfway through the film.

The film truly is beautiful, and while the translations are often corny ("Cut the crap" getting a hearty chuckle from my viewing group) the writing is beautiful. The song and dance numbers, as mentioned, are somewhat scarce but truly works of art when they arrive. Overall, I believe that if this work were to be adapted for an American audience if would find a great reception among the brooding, "Remains of the Day" kind of audience.

Anonymous said...

Bollywood Movie Review: Rang De Basanti
By: Nathan Parker
I loved this movie! This was the first Bollywood style film I have seen. It is about a girl in England named Sue McKinley who finds a diary that belonged to her grandfather, who was a prison guard during the Indian independence movement. In the diary it talks about five freedom fighters that were active in the movement. She decides to make a movie about these freedom fighters and casts Daljit, Karan, Aslam, Sukhi, and Laxman. Throughout the movie they realize that their lives are not so different from the people they are trying to portray.
During this movie Ajay, a flight Lieutenant in the Indian airforce, is killed when his plane crashes. The government blamed it all on pilot error but knowing that Ajay was a superb pilot, the cast began to question whether the government’s findings were true or not. After doing some digging, they find out that a corrupt government leader had signed off on the cause of the accident. Unfortunately, Karan’s father was one of the group that covered up the real facts concerning the accident. They had been installing cheap, substandard parts which caused fatal crashes over several years time – all of which they blamed on pilot error.
After finding this out, the cast helped form a peaceful protest at Ajay’s memorial site at the India Gate. Police start forcefully breaking up the protest by hitting the people with their batons. In the process of doing this, the police put Ajay’s mother into a coma.
The cast remembered that their characters in the script used violence to gain justice. They decided to kill the minister and Karan’s father for their part in murdering the pilots. However, the media instead of portraying them as freedom fighters, labelled them as terrorists. To explain their position, the cast went to a local radio station, forced the people in the building to leave at gunpoint threw away their guns and went on the air to tell people why they did it. As people called in and the cast answered their questions they were killed by the police and military. The final scene was of Ajay’s mother coming out of her coma.
I really enjoyed the dancing and the music in this movie. Even though this movie went on forever, the music and dancing kept you engaged enough that it seemed like the movie was a minute long. The music set up the scences perfectly; the emotion of the music brought the scene to life. It brought you into to what every character was feeling. The choreography was amazing. All the dancers were together and nobody was off beat.
I really enjoyed this movie and encourage everyone to watch this film. It is in a different style, but you will love it.

Design said...

Jamison britton
world music
8:00 am

In the readings I really like the section which talked about the early sound methods. with synchronous sound among other things... reading It reminded me of the scene in singing in the rain when the studio begins recording for talking pictures and how sound used to be sinked up even up into the sixties with separate audio tracks. very neat.
As with any growth and popularity there will be changes... with bollywood films grossing more than ten times productions costs it would be expected to see kindof a sell out mentality.... but it seems as though the indian culture has keep the demand for musical and culturally strong stories. The hindi films remind me of disney films as far as their format... the musical structure and character developement.
For me i think the biggest surprise is to find out how large and widespread the indian film industrie is.... for the most part hollywood films are a worldwide phenomenom. many of todays blockbusters are seen internationally and so to me (as a narrowminded american) i just figured thats all there was.... but it seems to be that India has an even more devoted and core group of followers to their own bollywood style. I would say the bollywood section was a good way to start the class.

Anonymous said...

"Brief Reading" by Kabir
Review by Jason Evans

I really enjoyed this article. The main thing that really impressed my throughout the entire article was how throughout the history of Bollywood films, the appeal of the music has always been its central focus and how it has permeated and still permeates the culture on a massive scale. I looked at our culture today, and music does play a significant role in most of our lives in some form or another. But I noticed that here, it is mostly an internal event than public. I-pods, Pandora, etc. can be seen in use everywhere nowadays, but there really isn't any widespread public use on a daily basis that people share together, unless it's a specific concert, dance, etc. But contrast that with India's rich history of music within film and it's quite amazing. The music permeates every level of society. Music within film, unlike American films where non-background (theme type) music is avoided like the plaque, it is embraced as a true art form in India. The depths of seriousness that is taken in India is remarkable and I like it! The power of music is clearly evident and is used to its greatest potential in Bollywood film making and I really admire that. How street performers play the music and how the songs become truly pop sensations is another remarkable aspect. The amount of films made is also very remarkable. My overall reaction to this article was one of amazement. How music in films is so embraced by the popular culture and how here in America its avoided like the plague is very fascinating to me. I wonder why that is? That would be a very interesting topic for conversation.

Rachael said...

Bollywood Movie Review: Kal Ho Naa Ho
Rachael Purser

This movie had all sorts of emotions projecting throughout it, just like all the other movies. It was sad but happy, exciting and somewhat irritating but overall it was a good movie. I watched this movie maybe five-ish times before I started getting tired of it! The music was lively and made you want to get up and dance around or try singing along with them. The dance scenes were spectacular! Their outfits were amazing with all the vibrant colors. Even just the dialogue was spectacular.
I loved all the songs from the “Pretty Woman” remake to the “Mahive” to “It’s time to Disco.” If I had to choose a favorite song from this movie, it would be a tie between “Pretty Woman” and “Mahive.” I loved “Pretty Woman” because of the way they portrayed Americans. I found it funny that all of the “American’s” were dressed in clothing that was worn years before they made Kal Ho Naa Ho. I also loved how they had a random American flag suddenly drop behind them so they could have a spontaneous talent show of sorts. My family’s favorite part of this music and dance number was the random gospel choir walking down the street. Mainly it was funny to see how they saw us as Americans. “Mahive” was a favorite because of how traditional it was. I loved how cute it was with Preity Zinta’s mom was singing to her. I also adored the portrayal of true love from Shahrukh Khan to Preity Zinta in that he was willing to help her best friend win her heart when he truly loved her.
The ending line of this movie has stuck with me since the first time I heard it. I believe that it is because I am a bit of a romantic but it also has a great message. “Most girls’ dream of finding a best friend in their husbands, I was lucky enough to find a husband in my best friend.” I loved this line and it has stuck with me ever since I watched this movie. I love how Bollywood portrays true love, friendship and the importance of family in most, if not all, of their movies. This movie was remarkable and I would definitely recommend it to anyone that wanted to be introduced to Bollywood or who was interested in Bollywood videos.

Nick rowley said...

"Reading" by Kabir

This article was very good. It was interesting to learn that in India music is more of an Art in the films. In America music is avoided in films. In India it is what truly makes a movie a good movie. The music is very important within the film and is what make the film great. In America a film can still be a good movie in our eyes even if the music within the film is not that great. It is also interesting to know that in India music plays a bigger part in their life and is a great art. Bollywood has done so well in India because of the music within the films. It is the focus of the movie, whereas I think that Hollywood wants good music in their films, but it is not the main focus. It also really surprised me in the amount of films that are produced in Bollywood. It is crazy to know that they have produced that many films. Overall I really enjoyed this article and it opened my eyes to a whole different and truly amazing culture.

Jeremiah said...

I should begin with a disclaimer. For the longest time, I thought that “Bollywood” was just a ripoff of Hollywood and really wasn’t all that good, even though I had never actually seen a Bollywood film. However, having read about what a typical Bollywood film includes – especially with how much time and effort is put into the musical aspect – I already have a high opinion for them.

The thing that stands out the most to me from the “Brief History of Bollywood Film Songs” reading is that the music is really central to the success of the movie. From the shorter reading, it seemed that ever since Bollywood began music took an ever increasing role of importance in the movies. It seems that while America sought an ever increasing amount of action and special effects in their movies, Avatar and Star Trek being two recent examples, India demanded musicals with ever increasing complexity. Along with this, I was intrigued with what the reading said about how unimportant a good story or action sequences are to the Indian audience, especially since that’s all Hollywood seems to do these days sometimes. For film viewers to want great music in films, even if it means using the same story over and over again, is something else that really stuck out to me.

Another thing that stuck out to me in the readings is that the films from Bollywood really make no sense whatsoever to Americans. Whereas Hollywood has several different genres of films, Bollywood really only has one – musicals. Also, the reading says that Bollywood films are similar to the “heterogeneous mode of production” where all the parts are assembled separately and then put together at the final point instead of gradually being put together stage by stage, which leaves the feeling of each component having its own uniqueness. I thought this was interesting because Hollywood movies don’t leave that kind of an impression with me.

Derek Rich said...

Bollywood Reading: World Music Bollywood Reading Kabir
by: Derek Rich

I enjoyed reading this for one reasons. First is that the author gives a valid reason to watch and be entertained by bollywood movies. The actors do not care for the acting but they will not do a movies if the music is not original. The actors are very picky on the music they will be singing to.
The author gives some history on bollywood music and movies. That back in the ’30s they sang live on set. Then progressively through the years they began to sing in studios. Plus hiring separate singers to help with people who can not sing as well.

Laura Swan Eldred said...

Laura Swan
I really enjoyed the Bollywood film Kuch Kuch Hota Hai(Something is Happening). The first half of the movie is a flashback to the college days when best friends Raul and tomboy Anjali played basketball every day and she would win. Then the Principal’s daughter Tina comes home from studying at Oxford in England to study at her Father’s college. Raul is smitten. Then in class one day Raul is asked what love is and says that it is friendship. He says it so that later he can ask Tina to be his friend but unknowingly makes Anjali realize that she has feelings for him. When Raul confesses to Anjali that he is in love with Tina, she breaks down and decides to leave school. They lose all communication.
Now into the present day nine years later. Tina and Raul had a baby girl but Tina died shortly after childbirth. She made Raul promise that he would name their baby Anjali. Tina wrote eight letters before she died to her daughter to give her on her birthday each year. Tina’s eighth letter was the flashback of the first half of the film. Then Tina asks Anjali to get Raul and the adult Anjali together.
There is one problem, Anjali is now getting engaged to Aman. However, with the help of her grandparents, the girl Anjali meets the woman she was named for by attending the song and dance camp that the adult Anjali works at every summer. Then she gets her dad to come (Aman is in England at first).
I kept having to explain the plot as people would walk into the room I was watching this film in. It was harder to understand and appreciate the music and dancing scenes if you didn’t understand the plot.
The film was made in 1998 but the first half of the movie looks like it was made in the 80’s, which makes sense because it is a flashback to nine years previously. The first song was about how Raul and Anjali thought the other was a crazy person. The same phrases were repeated many times but it wasn’t repetitive because the scenes, groups, and clothing kept on changing. There is a part where Tina has to sing a song in Hindi because that is the “rule” of the school for new students that Raul is enforcing. She sings the song beautifully then tells Raul that just because she has been living in London she has not forgotten her roots.
I really love the entire sequence of the song Sajan Ji Ghar Aaye where Anjali is getting engaged; this could be because of the ethnic costumes and dancing in them. There is a part where her mother is singing about how much she is going to miss her daughter and you can hear in the music her sadness. I had the tune stuck in my head for days. You can watch the clip at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=feBpJmHCl0U While Anjali is getting engaged, Tina’s family is remembering her on the day that she died. The girl Anjali is dressing up exactly as the adult Anjali did the last time Raul saw her so he imagines that her sees the adult Anjali.
There is another really fun sequence where from when they are at camp and Raul and the adult Anjali are starting to fall for each other. One of the children is pretending to play the violin showing the English influence that we talked about in class.
I would highly recommend this movie. It takes a little bit to get into it but once you do you will want to know how it all works out.

The bor said...

Movie Review: Dhoom 2

The 1st thing I will say is, this movie is not quite what I expected. This must be one of the newer generation of Bollywood flicks. It had 2 mildly intamate smooches, and in the beginning they had a commentary about how 90% of hubbies that have affairs have affairs when their wives are pregnant.
Those interesting things aside this was a good movie. I found it quite interesting that when the action got really intense the sound got really quiet, along with the music. Opposite of American movies. Also the men's dancing in this I thought was better than the women's. This is completly opposite of what I usually think. My wife and I are huge fans of SYTYCD, and bollywood is one of our fav. styles (Joshua, and Katie :^)
THe muse and dance were awesome. This movie was definitly more western it even had a large amount of english singing in it.
Oh the sense of humor they use in this movie is absolutly wonderful. I laughed a lot. The action sequenses were very dramatic and drawn out, but still good. Lots of "yeah right" moments, which I admit I miss in american moives.

Anonymous said...

Movie: Like Stars on Earth
by: Matthew Law

This movie was excellently made, and a lot better than I thought it might be. It does seem to be a bit westernized, and the fact that it came from Disney might have a big part in that. Anyways, the film is very different than what I was expecting, a lot more sad in the journey than one would think, and it was all well played off by the music.
The start shows right off the bat that the main character, Ishaan, has something different with him. He doesn't do well in school, is bullied, and really wants to express himself. Not long after that, it shows the completely different views of his family, through song of course. There's an audible and visible difference between how they think just of the competition of the world, getting farther along, and how Ishaan sees the beauty in everything, often running away in his imagination.
This ends up causing problems later, and he is sent off to boarding school where he becomes broken and depressed. A new teacher, unable to stand how he feels, looks for a way to help him feel better.
One of my favorite things about this film, is it really shows what life is like for those that are misunderstood. They don't fit in the current norm, and so they are shunned by many of their peers, and just everyone in general. This is shown by the song Jame Raho, seen at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OdmGUry6Q8o
Many of those people end up like Ishaan was for a good portion of the movie, broken and depressed. That seems to happen too much in the world these days. But, there are many people too, who like the other main character, Ram, see the pain in their lives, and also who those people can really be. They try their best to bring that out, so that it really shines, thus the title Like Stars on Earth.
I really recommend that everyone watch this, because it was such a great movie, and emotional as well. It really gets you thinking, which I take as a sign of an accomplished movie. The music added so much to it, and made it all the better.

charleslilly said...

Charles Lilly re. Lagaan.... Wow what a way to set up a game of cricket and prove a point as well. The acting was superb; The music, especially the drum's was outstanding; And how the village just stepped up to the plate. I don't understand why this movie did not at least win an Oscar for the music and the dancing; I mean gosh, so many Hollywood flicks are just so plain jane compared to Lagaan..... Also the cinematography, the camera positioning from an artist's point of view; This was so superb. The one thing from a musical outlook was the key's of the material I think could have been negotiated a little better; But everybody has something to say about everything; other than that I can't find a single other problem with this amazing production..... Great cast, obviously alote of thought went into the editing as well; I would like to see this on Broadway with well established Hollywood elite stumbling over themselves; I really think it would turn into a crazier comedy, you know? at any rate, Lagaan I highly recommend; Rub an English face into the dirt of a cricket field; just joking.....

Unknown said...

Reading One

I find the bollywood movies vary intresting. I don't mean to make anyone mad, but I really can't stand there movies at all, and I am not saying anyone is stupide for liking them eather. I can understand how you would like it, its just not my cup of tea.

There movies are full of excitment, love, and happyness. I was kind of shocked to see how good there movies are doing, they are suprisingly vary poular. I think it is cool how close they are to their music. you can tell how much they love doing it. Another thing I love is how involed everyone is. In America there is tones of people who lison to the music but only a few who acually play it and are involed in cultural events. In Indea everyone knows how to do something. Be it danceing, singing, or playing the insterments they all do something.

Unknown said...

Reading 2 Bollywood Spectaculars

I liked how it is in a first person view. It helps you to see how they feel about bollywood. I thought it was cool that the film Lagaan was nominated for an Oscar in the best foreign film category. I also thought it was cool how the New York Times raved about it. It just goes to show you how popular bollywood is geting. You always see some type of bollywood dance group in one of the dance shows on tv, and they are geting lots of prase on thouse shows as well. I think that it is cool that there are some bollywood films that are trying to progect a more realalistic would, Insede of a fun happy film where they guy always gets his girl, and there is lots of people danceing. I did not know that India has a MTV chanall also. I really injoyed reading this it had tones of cood facts that I did not know.

Cherise Jenkins said...

Cherise Jenkins
Bollywood: Kabir readings
I think the chronological presentation of Bollywood films was wise and quite effective. Through it I was able to see the transformation of Bollywood. I thought it was rather interesting that in the beginning, music was dubbed into the film like it is done now, but two microphones was used during the filming, one placed by the actor/actress that was singing and the other placed by the musicians playing the music, often just a sarangi and a tabla player. This made the points of interest the singer/actor and the music composition. The cinema was not that amazing, but the picture of the singer remained in Indians’ minds. Later on as technology developed, dubbing became more popular and famous singers were willing to lend their voices for the dubbing. The cinema quality improved. At time passed, Bollywood was infamous for all the music and it was not until the 90’s that their music was recognized as a good quality among western countries. I thought the change from synchronization of music and acting at the beginning of the Bollywood career was interesting. It was not talked about in class. I had thought that Bollywood always used dubbing in their productions. Discovering that that was not the case in the very beginning is cool. I think the beginning experiences with synchronized acting and singing may be a reason why Bollywood continues to dub their music today, though my speculation may be wrong.